A Conversation for 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary [Peer Review version]

Peer Review: A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 1

Icy North

Entry: 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary - A87774592
Author: Icy North - U225620

Greetings, Peer Reviewers.

This is quite a geeky entry, but I hope some of you find the subject as interesting as I did.

Comments and suggestions welcome smiley - smiley

smiley - cheers Icy


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 2

Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor

This is fun. smiley - smiley As always.

I have one timid question: is 'have weaved' correct in the UK? I know I end up asking this about every strong verb that used to be in the English language, but I'm used to 'have woven'. smiley - laugh


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 3

Icy North

Thanks Dmitri,

I only put these things to test whether people read it smiley - whistle

Oh, did you spot the crude attempt to avoid a word being trapped by the profanity filter?


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 4

Z

Great fun! Really enjoyed this one.

Z


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 5

Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor

smiley - rofl Having been informed by a fellow Guide Editor as to the inappropriateness of the word 'n0nce' over there, er, yes...smiley - whistle


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 6

AE Hill, Mabin-OGion Character of inauspicious repute

Wow, why didn’t someone do this before? [smiles]

Brilliant.

Given that this article is so brilliant, I ask you if you want to polish your *Guide’s entry* so as not to confuse me which Guide, h2g2 or Adams’. It is technically there, but OED could have referenced h2g2 [smiles] and you are publishing in the h2g2 Guide.

*Looking through the OED's Hitchhiker's quotations, Some are more obvious than others. Perhaps the best known of them is the Guide's entry on Space:*>> is that Guide’s entry

AE smiley - cool


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 7

Nosebagbadger {Ace}

This is a brilliant entry! smiley - biggrin

My knowledge would say that "I have weaved" and "I have woven" would both be correct, someone is free to check if they wish


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 8

Icy North

Thanks all smiley - ok

I've replaced 'Guide' in that context with the lowercase 'guide', AE. Hope this is clearer. smiley - smiley


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 9

You can call me TC

I was half way through before I realised that I wasn't seeing the quotes. (They come up white on white in Goo/Firefox) So I marked it all and started again.

Aaah! smiley - eureka - now it makes sense!


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 10

Icy North

White on white in Goo/Firefox! Good grief smiley - erm

Ever thought of switching either your browser or your h2g2 default skin? I can attest that Alabaster works well on all popular browsers.


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 11

You can call me TC

In that light: smiley - applausesmiley - applausesmiley - applausesmiley - applause

How did you find all that out?

On Recumbentman's behalf - is there any chance of slotting in a link to the OED in limerick form? It's nothing to do with the entry directly, but as he is a major contributor, it deserves a plug.


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 12

Icy North

Show me the limerick and I'll see if it fits (although I'm concerned about it breaking the flow of this entry)


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 13

You can call me TC

No - not changing browser or skin. I'll just sit here and suffer. I have to Ctrl-A lots of pages which come up white-on-white (my conversations for example)


Anyway, I thought maybe you could just reference with a link on the side of the page - not incorporated into the entry. If not - have a look round anyway, it's very interesting.

http://www.oedilf.com



A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 14

Nosebagbadger {Ace}

I kind of expect to see TC sitting on a rocking chair on a porch clutching a rifle shouting "get orff my property, vermin!"

I also am interested in how you found them - did you just access the OED and search hitchhikers (or similar)?


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 15

Icy North

The trick is to use the 'advanced search' button, Nbb. It allows you to search authors smiley - smiley

DNA had 32 Hitchhiker quotations as well as two from Dirk Gently and a couple of other miscellaneous ones - about 35-40 in all.

...but did he have more or fewer than Terry Pratchett?


Hi TC, what's the OED link to that limerick site? And what's the Douglas Adams link, come to think of it?


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 16

Nosebagbadger {Ace}

He must have fewer quotes than Terry Pratchett, he crops up all over the place - and that's assuming that the words he makes up aren't cited in the news commonly enough to be classified proper words - in which case they'd all have to be quoted back


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 17

Icy North

The score is DNA 35, Pratchett 25 smiley - smiley

OK, who wins out of Dan Brown versus JK Rowling?


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 18

Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor

Well, I hope 'headology' gets into the OED sometime. I use it...smiley - run


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 19

Recumbentman

Thank you, TC, for describing me as a 'major contributor' to OEDILF (the Omnificent English Dictionary in Limerick Form). I have contributed a mere 170 approved limericks, which places me 94th in the list: the top contributor has had over 9,000 accepted.

There are currently 15 limericks there mentioning Douglas Adams: http://www.oedilf.com/db/Lim.php?button=Search&Word=Douglas%20Adams&Start=0

Originally called 'The Oxford English Dictionary in Limerick Form', OEDILF's name was changed when Oxford demurred. Why they were ever asked to accept the homage in the first place beats me.


A87774592 - 'Hitchhiker' Quotations in the Oxford English Dictionary

Post 20

Icy North

Thanks Recumbentman,

I think to mention the OEDILF in this entry would be confusing, but it would make a fascinating subject for a separate entry, if you or anyone else was inclined to write it?

smiley - cheers Icy


Key: Complain about this post