A Conversation for THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
Peer Review: A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
The_Reluctant_Gaijin Started conversation Jan 5, 2010
Entry: THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X - A61427586
Author: The_Reluctant_Gaijin - U14251170
Although this is written in the first person, it is experiential and invites the reader to imagine themselves in the same situation. Anything stated as fact has been checked and whilst opinions are also given, this is because the article is meant as part of a learning process and this aids persepctive.
A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
Vip Posted Jan 5, 2010
It's an interesting tale, and I'm interested in hearing the rest of it.
Unfortunately, Peer Review is not the right place for it. The Edited Guide is only for factual Entries, not personal accounts. Have a look at the Writing-Guidelines.
You could look at submitting your series to <./>ThePost</.>, h2g2's very own newspaper, or to the <./>Underguide</.>, which has a focus on fictional Entries and personal accounts, just like yours.
I hope this doesn't put you off, and that we get to read about the rest of your exploits in Japan!
Vip
Scout
A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
Vip Posted Jan 5, 2010
Oh, I forgot to mention - could you remove this Entry from Peer Review for us? Go to the <./>Peer Review</.> page, scroll down to the bottom of the screen and click on the word 'Remove' to the right hand side of your Entry.
A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
h5ringer Posted Jan 5, 2010
Greetings to The_Reluctant_Gaijin
While Vip is quite right to advise you that your piece doesn't fit the requirements for the Edited Guide, please don't go away or be discouraged. It is good material and can find a home elsewhere on the site. Vip has suggested <./>ThePost</.> and the <./>UnderGuide</.>; as a regular contributor to The Post myself, I'm naturally biased but either area of the site would be suitable. I've taken the liberty of pointing your submission out the Post's Editor, just in the (unlikely) case that she had missed it.
Welcome to h2g2 and I hope something can be developed from this start. Well done for writing it
h5ringer
Scout
A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
Lanzababy - Guide Editor Posted Jan 5, 2010
I'd like to endorse all the previous posts - and welcome the new writer Reluctant Gaijin to the h2g2.
Pleased to meet you too
Lanzababy Scout
A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
The_Reluctant_Gaijin Posted Jan 8, 2010
Vip - Thanks for your reply and I have submitted my article to The Post. I tried to unsubmit it from Peer Review but either went in a loop or got a page not found error message, sorry...
The_Reluctant_Gaijin
A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
The_Reluctant_Gaijin Posted Jan 8, 2010
h5ringer - Thanks also for your postive feedback. I have just looped around yet again, in an affort to remove my article from Peer Review and submit it to the Underguide (I have, I think, submitted it to The Post, by regular e-mail, but I don't know which place will want it). I am getting a lot of pages telling me why I should or shouldn't make submissions to various places, but cannot find a way to actually remove and submit. I may be internet-retarded or the navigation of this site may be tricky...
The_Reluctant_Gaijin
A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
Lanzababy - Guide Editor Posted Jan 8, 2010
>>>I may be internet-retarded or the navigation of this site may be tricky...
I don't believe the first half of this sentence, but the second half is definitely true.
You will find a {remove} link next to your User ID at the right hand side of this Entry on the PeerReview page
Did you try to remove your article this way? I've never done it myself, so I don't know what happens. I'm sorry you are having problems.
Lanzababy
A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
Vip Posted Jan 8, 2010
If you can't, don't worry. It will get removed by the Eds in a while anyway (note to self: let the Eds know that this needs removing). I'm afraid I've never tried to remove anything either, so I don't know what hoops you have to jump through.
This site isn't the easiest to navigate, so don't worry! I'm just glad you're enthusiastic and want to contribute.
Key: Complain about this post
Peer Review: A61427586 - THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
- 1: The_Reluctant_Gaijin (Jan 5, 2010)
- 2: Vip (Jan 5, 2010)
- 3: Vip (Jan 5, 2010)
- 4: h5ringer (Jan 5, 2010)
- 5: toybox (Jan 5, 2010)
- 6: Lanzababy - Guide Editor (Jan 5, 2010)
- 7: The_Reluctant_Gaijin (Jan 8, 2010)
- 8: The_Reluctant_Gaijin (Jan 8, 2010)
- 9: Lanzababy - Guide Editor (Jan 8, 2010)
- 10: Vip (Jan 8, 2010)
More Conversations for THE RELUCTANT GAIJIN Part I of X
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."