A Conversation for Philip Lampi - The Itinerant Historian

Peer Review: A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 1

J

Entry: Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home - A53069682
Author: Jordan - Three entries and a cloud of dust - U201497

Now, let me stress something. Lampi is an obscure character. I had to tap every vine I saw just to get the relatively short entry before you. If there are gaps in the story or points where more detail would be nice, please know that I agree and wish there was more information on the guy. There are a few things I'm not sure of and that I've had to sort of ignore:
smiley - biro I wish I knew what kind of car he drove around and slept in.
smiley - biro I am not 100% certain that he's not married, but a picture I saw of him doesn't show a wedding ring and one source made a sort of passing reference to his remaining alone.
smiley - biro I wish I knew more about where he went in his big tour in 1973.

Anyway, please review. I'm not in love with the title, by the way, if anyone has a suggestion.

Thanks,
Jordan


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 2

Icy North

Very enjoyable read - thank you very much for submitting this! smiley - ok

I appreciate what the guy has done - collation of raw electoral data - but how exactly has this benefitted the nation? Do you have any examples of how it is used, eg subsequent academic studies or analysis based on Lampi's data?

smiley - cheers Icy


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 3

Icy North

Just had a quick search for Lampi. I can't add a lot to what you've already written.

I guess you saw the article 'The Orphan Scholar' in the journal 'Humanities' and a Boston Globe article on January 20, 2008: "Filling election gaps A man's passion for results helps write some history". These tie in with your entry.

The only other reference I found doesn't answer your three questions, but it does describe Lampi's view on free-access to data.

An article in the Wilkes Barre Times Leader, July 26, 2004, describes how history professor Harold Cox set up a free-access election statistics database, using Lampi's data.

"... in 1996 when Cox approached a consortium of universities that collect similar statistics, asking for some 19th-century election records. He was told he would need to pay more than $1,000."

The article then describes Cox's initial conversation with Lampi at the American Antiquarian Society:

Cox: "Do you have any of this (polling) information?"

Lampi: "Yes."

Cox: "May I have access to it?"

Lampi: "Sure."

Cox: "What's it going to cost me?"

Lampi: "Nothing. Knowledge is meant to be shared."


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 4

aka Bel - A87832164

Nice entry, Jordan. I wish I could contribute something, but google.de asked me whether I meant 'Philip Lampe' (meaning lamp) and gave me lots of links to light bulbs, and Brockhaus (our equivalent to the Encyclopaedia Britannica) only mentions some Johann Baptiste Lampi the elder, an Austrian 18th Century painter, and his son.


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 5

Icy North

I agree that 'The Historian with No Home' may not be the best. He had a home, I should have thought - he just slept in his car at weekends sometimes.

'The Historian Who Slept In His Car'?
'The Itinerant Historian'?
'The Man Who Loved Only Electoral Statistics'?


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 6

J

Thanks for that Icy, I hadn't seen that tiny Lampi snippet. I had two other sources, which I sort of really had to dig for. Unfortunately all of my sources are online, which I generally try to avoid if I can help it. There's been at least one occasion when I wrote an entry based off online sources and when I was finished, I checked the wikipedia page, only to find that whoever wrote that wiki was apparently using the same sources, so our entries had exactly the same info - just written much differently. Luckily, Philip Lampi has no wikipedia entry. smiley - smiley

"I appreciate what the guy has done - collation of raw electoral data - but how exactly has this benefitted the nation? Do you have any examples of how it is used, eg subsequent academic studies or analysis based on Lampi's data?"

Not much yet, as far as I know. The only major conclusion that I understand to have come out of Lampi's work is about the importance of the Federalists as a regional party in New England after their collapse as a national party following the election of 1800. I think Lampi has helped to spread that conclusion himself, though.
If you do a google search with "Philip Lampi" in quotation marks like that, most of the results are simply studies or journals with references to his data in footnotes and parentheses, saying "data compiled by Philip Lampi, American Antiquarian Society" or something similar. It's being used, I think, bit by bit. I'm afraid I don't have any great example to offer.

The English google asks if I meant "philip lamp" also. As I say, not a very well known guy. If I type in my own full name to google, it doesn't try to correct me. smiley - winkeye

I went with "Historian with no home" mostly for the alliteration, I'll admit. I like "The Itinerant Historian" best of those three, Icy, and better than the current title. Let's see if others have more ideas.


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 7

aka Bel - A87832164

I get interesting results when googling for your full name:

>>Looking for Hip Woman's Beach Wear? [name removed] Carries The Hottest Beach Wear For Women. Check Out Our Large Selection of Beachwear!<<


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 8

J

smiley - biggrin
The wikipedia page for one of the Hanson brothers used to be the first result. Now I see it's dropped to fifth. But then my name is much less common than Mr. Lampi's.


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 9

J

Much *more* common, I mean to say.


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 10

Elentari

Wonderful entry, Jordan.


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 11

J

Thanks El. I'm a bit nervous writing about someone who's still alive. smiley - smiley

Icy, I added a short sentence saying that his info has been used in a lot of academic studies.


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 12

AlexAshman


"I'm a bit nervous writing about someone who's still alive."

Don't be. You've done a good job.


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 13

Icy North

"I'm a bit nervous writing about someone who's still alive."

That can be resolved fairly easily.

*muffled bang*


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 14

Elentari

smiley - bluelightsmiley - handcuffs


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 15

J

smiley - cross
You'd just be creating more work for me as a biographer, you know, by creating mysterious death circumstances.


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 16

aka Bel - A87832164

But you wouldn't need to update the entry. smiley - tongueincheek


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 17

J

I've added a few links and changed a few things.


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 18

8584330

Very enjoyable read.smiley - smiley


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 19

J

Thanks. smiley - smiley

Unfortunately, while testing the GuideML of another entry in progress, I accidentally deleted the current draft of this entry, so I had to go back to the draft stored on my computer smiley - sigh It's not much different and I've made most of the alterations again that I made during the time it's been in PR, so hopefully I've not done much harm by being a complete and utter moron.

Anyone happen to have a clever idea for the title?


A53069682 - Philip Lampi - The Historian with No Home

Post 20

J

"It must be boring, Phil."

"What must be?"

"Just... waiting for three weeks for someone to notice you."

"Boring? Well, I've waited longer for less."

"Fair enough. I guess I just thought you've waited long enough."

"Well, nobody had written an entry about me in the nine years h2g2 has been around. They might never have. A few months' wait is understandable."


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for Philip Lampi - The Itinerant Historian

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more