A Conversation for George R R Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire

Hey

Post 1

Orcus

Nice to see a fellow fan on h2g2 smiley - smiley
I look forward to seeing this article finished

Amazon have got A Dance With Dragons already on sale. Unfortunatley you havbe to prebook cos its not out until June 2002 smiley - sadface

BTW, I thought a Clash of Kings was the best one. Mainly because I thought the latest book had a misleading title. The second book was far more of 'A Storm of Swords' than the third smiley - erm
Just my opinion.

The Red Wedding had me on the floor in shock mind.

smiley - cheers

Orcus


Hey

Post 2

RedFish ><>

ooo someone looked at it!!!

Yes I agree the title of book 3 was misleading...

dont get ur hopes up about book 3 being on time, my dad was GRRM's editor for a while, he sint punctual...

I have permission from GRRM to put up to 500 words from one of the books in as an exerpt... any suggestions?


Hey

Post 3

Orcus

You do!? smiley - wow

I would talk to the italics directly about that. smiley - erm
I suspect they'd need permission in writing for that (in fact I'm sure of it).

Somthing that isn't a spoiler I guess smiley - erm Most of the memorable scenes are unfortunately.

Strangely Amazon have got an exact number of pages down for book 4 - how do they know this when presumably it isn't even finished yet (and if it is - why isn't is already on the press).

Not punctual? He's not Robert Jordan in disguise is he? smiley - winkeye


Hey

Post 4

RedFish ><>

Good point, I'll talk to them...

unfortunately GRRM gave me permission in an instant messanger chat so i cant prove it, but i could email him i guess

I imagine that the publishers told amazon the number of pages as an estimate as he will be aiming at a specific number... did you know when AGOT came out there were only four books planned? He has gone overboard on this series methinks smiley - smiley


Hey

Post 5

Orcus

Stop! You're scaring me.

I don't know if you read Robert Jordan's wheel of time but that started out as a planned four books. Currently it's nine with no end in sight and at least two years between books. smiley - grr
Good as it is, it's now begining to wear very thin and the enthusiasm for it has completely gone off now.

You definitely won't get something like that in without written permission by the author or publishers. Someone once tried to put an article on building a campfire through Peer Review. It was written by another and had been put into some sort of real life scout circular magazine. The author of the article put a note at the bottom of the article saying something like 'I give my permission for this to be used on h2g2'. It wasn't enough - copyright laws require stringent proof in such cases and this wasn't sufficient. Twas all well in the end though. The article was simply rewritten and it debuted on the front page only a few weeks ago.


Hey

Post 6

RedFish ><>

I think that regarding books copyright may allow for excerpts... ill ask my dad today, cos he is in publishing, and he might be able to get a letter from GRRM... who knows...

Anyway, I have emailed the italics and they are thinking about it...


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for George R R Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more