A Conversation for The Animorphs Book Series

Peer Review: A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 1

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

Entry: The Animorphs Book Series - A2205758
Author: Hussassan the Silicon Samurai - Proud User of Alabaster - U200779

I was surprised we didn't already have an edited entry on this - tell me what you think.


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 2

Z

I've not read the series though I've been told about it. This is a good entry. I would be intrested to know what age group these books are aimed at. Are there fan websites you could link to?

Good work smiley - ok


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 3

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

Well, they seem to be aimed a 12-16 year-olds, but have a lesser version of the 'Harry Potter' effect, in that many older people like them as well. Another entry on this site mentions a fansite, just give me a minute to find it.


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 4

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

http://www.morphz.com

I have yet to check it out, though.


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 5

frenchbean

Hi Hussassan smiley - smiley

I haven't read these books either, but am inspired to go find some now! smiley - ok I really enjoyed this entry. However, I do have some comments (trust me, I'm not picking on you!)smiley - winkeye

It'ld be worth putting the entry through a spell-checker. I picked up a heap of typos: too many to list here smiley - puff

How do they un-morph...smiley - erm is it the same way they morph?

Andalites pop up pretty early on, but you don't say what they are until much later... could do with a footnote to say that. Or alternatively, change the running-order round, so the characters come before the books. Hmm, not sure that would work. Just a suggestion. Ignore as you wish!

What are ?

What are ?

and are mixed up quite a lot, especially in para 5. Might be worth sticking with one or the other, not both: it kind of spoils the flow...smiley - erm

Is Visser Three an alien? And Erek? If so, they need to be under the Aliens section

How come the Yeerks use the Hork-Bajir for combat if the latter are so peaceful?

Then at the end it just stops! Some kind of conclusion would be good...

Good stuff

smiley - cheers
F/b


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 6

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

"It'ld be worth putting the entry through a spell-checker. I picked up a heap of typos: too many to list here"

OK

"How do they un-morph... is it the same way they morph?"

Yes

"What are ?"

smiley - erm Not quite sure where that is, I'll get back to you...

"What are ?"

People under Yeerk control.

" and are mixed up quite a lot, especially in para 5. Might be worth sticking with one or the other, not both: it kind of spoils the flow..."

OK

"Is Visser Three an alien? And Erek? If so, they need to be under the Aliens section"

They are aliens, but I put them in the character section as they appear regularly. The aliens section is mainly for races, Crayak being the exception, because he only appear twice in the whole series.

"How come the Yeerks use the Hork-Bajir for combat if the latter are so peaceful?"

I think the answer here is that they take control of the Hork-Bajir's bodies.

"Then at the end it just stops! Some kind of conclusion would be good..."

I'll see what I can do.


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 7

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

'Tellers' has been changed to 'Narrators.' I'll write a conclusion over the weekend.


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 8

frenchbean

smiley - ok Just let us know when you've added stuff...

smiley - cheers
F/b


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 9

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

Just made another update.


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 10

frenchbean

Hi there smiley - smiley

I'll look at it tomorrow. I'm pooped and need my bed now smiley - yawnsmiley - zzz

F/b


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 11

Geggs

I like this. I did spot a typo though - I think you spelt 'afraid' wrong in the section on Rachel.

Also, do you think you would be able to add some links in? I know there's some entries on Harry Potter, sci-fi, and other this referenced in the entry lying around here somewhere. Is there a good website dedicated to the series that you could point us to as well?

But as I say, these are just small matters. I really do like this entry.


Geggs


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 12

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

I've added some links and stuff...


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 13

frenchbean

Hello there smiley - smiley

I've only had time for a quickish look. I like the links and edits.

I asked the questions in post 5 because I thought the answers might improve the entry smiley - smiley And although you answered my questions in post 6, those clarifications don't seem to have made it to the entry smiley - erm Are you planning to make it clearer what a controller is, or a footnote on andalites etc?

smiley - cheers
Fb


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 14

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

Actually, I did add a footnote as to what a Controller is, maybe you missed it...smiley - erm


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 15

Cat-Eyes: No..... why.... ?

I really liked it. It's very well researched. I think I might have seen a typo, but I can't find it now... smiley - biggrin

Bye!
Cat


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 16

frenchbean

smiley - doh My apologies Hussassan smiley - grovel I did miss it

*wanders off, muttering about not speed reading entries in future...*

F/b


A2205758 - The Animorphs Book Series

Post 17

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

*Pats Frenchbean on the back.*

there, there, we all make mistakes. Here, have some smiley - cake and smiley - choc


Congratulations - Your Entry has been Picked for the Edited Guide!

Post 18

h2g2 auto-messages

Your Guide Entry has just been picked from Peer Review by one of our Scouts, and is now heading off into the Editorial Process, which ends with publication in the Edited Guide. We've therefore moved this Review Conversation out of Peer Review and to the entry itself.

If you'd like to know what happens now, check out the page on 'What Happens after your Entry has been Recommended?' at EditedGuide-Process. We hope this explains everything.

Thanks for contributing to the Edited Guide!


Congratulations - Your Entry has been Picked for the Edited Guide!

Post 19

Geggs

Congratulations! smiley - applause


Geggs


Congratulations - Your Entry has been Picked for the Edited Guide!

Post 20

frenchbean

Well done! smiley - applausesmiley - bubbly

F/b


Key: Complain about this post