A Conversation for A Brief Guide to Scouting

Peer Review: A1159751 - A Brief Guide to Scouting

Post 1

Z

Entry: A Brief Guide to Scouting - A1159751
Author: Dr Zen - U185843

I wrote this a guide for Scouts in 2005, and then never did much with it.

Actually looking at it again I realise it's actually fairly useful, and maybe it should be an official help page for scouts.

Any thoughts people?


A1159751 - A Brief Guide to Scouting

Post 2

Z

Other than the fact that this is the longest delay in history between creating entry and entering it into PR. Nearly 7 years.


A1159751 - A Brief Guide to Scouting

Post 3

Lanzababy - Guide Editor

Alex has updated this page recently I believe?

<./>Scouts-What</.>

It has a succinct account of the process - do you think it misses any salient points Dr Zen?



A1159751 - A Brief Guide to Scouting

Post 4

Not him

You know, I'm not sure this is Edited Guide material (although it's certainly now been brought to the scouts' attention) as it may be liable to change in line with BBC/h2g2 policies (scouts are now asked to make 3 picks, rather than 2, things like that) and is only relevant to a relatively small section of the population - much as an entry on how to write for the Edited Guide might not be included in it. It can all get a bit meta.


It does have a few extra useful links, for example, over Alex's page, (Writing Guidelines, ...) and examples of good deflections to other areas including the Underguide.


A1159751 - A Brief Guide to Scouting

Post 5

Z

Well true. I really entered it to bring it to the Scouts attention. I think actually I should have submitted it to the Writing Workshop..


A1159751 - A Brief Guide to Scouting

Post 6

h5ringer

The title on this needs changing. When I first saw this, I assumed it was an entry about Baden-Powell's Boy Scouts. It may be that I made the wrong connection so easily because I work as a volunteer with one of my local Scout troops, but anybody casually browsing hootoo is likely to make the same mistake.

h5ringer
Scout


A1159751 - A Brief Guide to Scouting

Post 7

Websailor

I thought exactly the same h5 but you beat me to it.

Websailor smiley - dragon


A1159751 - A Brief Guide to Scouting

Post 8

bobstafford

Where ever it goes (and its a good entry) can I suggest the title be ammended

from

A Brief Guide to Scouting

to something like

A Brief Guide to H2G2 Scouting
A Brief Guide for H2G2 Scouts

To avoid confusion in searches

smiley - smiley


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more