A Conversation for Language and Life - a Perspective on Species

more complications

Post 1

Nbcdnzr, the dragon was slain, and there was much rejoicing

To make things even more complicated, not even the line of reproduction is that strict. For example a horses and a donkey can have offspring smiley - chick, but this offspring smiley - chick can't have offspring smiley - chick of their own.

more complications

Post 2

Martin Harper

If they have an offspring chick, something is terribly wrong... smiley - erm


more complications

Post 3

Nbcdnzr, the dragon was slain, and there was much rejoicing

That would be interresting though, a horse laying an egg smiley - biggrin

more complications

Post 4


Thanks for reading my entry! smiley - ok

I think that hybridisation (and hybrid zones) is another issue, but maybe the mule is not such a good example. As it is sterile it really is (evolutionary-speaking) irrelevant.

There are some areas in Southern California and Florida where "Spanglish" is emerging as a mix of English and Spanish that immigrants bring into the country. There's also Mandarin and Cantonese in China, the same written language, but two different spoken languages. Mandarin is spoken in the north and Cantonese in the south. But a huge swathe of China in between can understand both, it is somewhat analogous to a hybrid zone where two diverged species meet and interbreed again.

I personally think species and languages are two sides of the same coin, the same problem.

Stesmiley - earth

more complications

Post 5


There is a slight error with this definition. It's not that individuals can breed to produce offspring. It's if they can breed together to produce FERTILE offspring. A horse and a donkey can interbreed to produce a mule but the mule is sterile (like Tom Cruise allegedly) and hence the horse and donkey are different species. If the mule were fertile then horses and donkeys would be the same species which could be called horkeys (which sounds like a way to get into a brothel), donses or mules. This definition is of course complicated by plants and flowers, but the less said about them the better.

Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more