A Conversation for Atheism

A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 21

AlexAshman


Ok, done smiley - ok

What do you think? smiley - smiley


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 22

AlexAshman


For ease of loading Entry:

Entry: Atheism - Update - A18396309
Author: Alex 'Tufty' Ashman [!] - U566116

(This is an update for A254477)


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 23

echomikeromeo

I like that, especially the quotes - I was smiley - yikes by that Bush one!


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 24

AlexAshman


Yep, me too - though it was a couple of decades ago, as far as I can tell. smiley - erm


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 25

taliesin

Looking good! smiley - ok

Have you seen this, btw?

http://www.samharris.org/site/full_text/10-myths-and-10-truths-about-atheism1/

smiley - cheers


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 26

Wyatt


Richard Dawkins, Billy Joel, Sigmund Freude, Katharine Hepburn, Penn Jillete and Teller, Ricky Gervaise, George Carlin, Isaac Asimov, Kurt Vonnegut, Salman Rushdie, Ayn Rand....


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 27

Wyatt


Whoops, I didn't see there was a second page. I was replying to the last post on the first page. Well, there's some more, anyway.


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 28

The H2G2 Editors

Nice work smiley - ok - do we agree this is ready then?


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 29

Gnomon - time to move on

As a strong atheist myself, I'm very impressed by this entry.smiley - smiley

My only concern with it is the footnote:

"At least the bunnies aren't associated with a multi-national carbonated drinks corporation."

This lends credence to the myth that Santa Claus was invented by a certain drinks company, when we all know this is not true.

I saw a wonderful painting of a saint wearing a red Santa hat in the National Gallery of Ireland last week. It dates from the 15th Century.


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 30

AlexAshman


"This lends credence to the myth that Santa Claus was invented by a certain drinks company, when we all know this is not true."

Yes, it's not true that they invented him, but it is still true that he is associated with the sale of certain beverages, which he is shown handing lovingly to young and old alike during the festive period. I've reworded the footnote smiley - ok

I've also added Billy Joel and added another misconception to the list.

Alex smiley - smiley


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 31

Gnomon - time to move on



We were watching a documentary about the devastation wreaked on New Orleans by Hurricane Katrina. There were shots of wrecked houses, flooded fields, overturned cars. One of the rescue workers commented: "if you want a coca cola, you have to go thirty miles up the road".

smiley - erm


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 32

AlexAshman


Only in the USA... smiley - ermsmiley - erm


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 33

IctoanAWEWawi

Good stuff.

Not sure if you want further comments or if this is off to one side for the purpose of this entry.

1 issue I think should be touched on, if only briefly, is that there are those who object to the term 'atheist' as it defines them in terms of something they are not. Or something they don;t believe in. Just to add to the variety of non believers!

Secondly, on the bits about questioning and searching for answers, is it worth mentioning Jesuit teaching which encourages questioning and exploration of all subjects?


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 34

AlexAshman


I think the Eds want to know if this is finished, but I'm quite happy to consider further comments. smiley - smiley

I think it's a little bit confusing to add that some atheists don't like being called atheists, although I must admit I once answered a questionnaire once with 'not even an atheist'. As for the Jesuits - they're not the sort of open-minded that means they are allowed to be truely atheist, so I don't think they really merit a mention here.


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 35

IctoanAWEWawi

ok, fair comments, your article after all!


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 36

the_jon_m - bluesman of the parish

as a wandering pagan, I think this is a very good and informative entry and well deserving of its place in the EG.


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 37

echomikeromeo

What Jon said.smiley - ok


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 38

AlexAshman


smiley - cheers I've finished working on it now, so it's ready now provided that everyone's happy with it.


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 39

IctoanAWEWawi

just waiting to see it on the front page now smiley - smiley


A18396309 - Atheism - Update

Post 40

Gnomon - time to move on

It's been updated. The new entry is now the official Edited Entry at A254477. I've put in a request for a Front Page Promo.


Key: Complain about this post