A Conversation for Halloween

Roman Catholic or Christian?

Post 1

Vestboy II not playing the Telegram Game at U726319

Was hallowe'en devised after the reformation and various other schisms? If not surely saying the Christian Church would be more accurate. Saying "Roman Catholic" makes it sound (comparatively) recent.


Roman Catholic or Christian?

Post 2

Kaz

When was the Roman Catholic church established? I thought Britain was Roman Catholic until old Henry had a schism. We became Christian in 600AD I think, but was that Christian or Catholic? Hummmmmmmmmmm?


Roman Catholic or Christian?

Post 3

Vestboy II not playing the Telegram Game at U726319

600 AD I'd say was Christian - it's even pre the East West split. (14th and 15th Century). I think issues around Rome came quite a bit later.


Roman Catholic or Christian?

Post 4

shagbark

perhaps dropping the word Roman and just saying Catholic would be sufficient.
Prior to the reformation all Christian Churches were Catholic.


Roman Catholic or Christian?

Post 5

Gnomon - time to move on

Prior to the Reformation, all Christians were just Christian. There was no such thing as Catholic or Protestant. So I've changed all the references from Catholic to Christian.


Roman Catholic or Christian?

Post 6

shagbark

the name Halloween derives from all Hallows Eve the night before All Saints Day. I have no idea how many centuries Christendum has celebrated that.


Roman Catholic or Christian?

Post 7

shagbark

I looked it up and Answer.com suggests
Germany and England began celebrating a feast of all martyrs and saints on 1 November in the 8th century, instead of on 13 May, as was done in Rome;
Other sites say Pope Gregory IV started it in the year 837.


Roman Catholic or Christian?

Post 8

Gnomon - time to move on

That's long before the Reformation.


Key: Complain about this post