This is the Message Centre for anachromaticeye

Wee Jock MacGuffin

Post 1

Bagpuss

Hello a_a_e,
I'm subbing your article on the MacGuffin. You'll see the new entry at A45377490. Let me know of any problems or suggestions.

The first thing you'll probably notice is the changed title - my dictionary insists that the G is capitalised. Other than that your footnotes have both disappeared I'm afraid. We can't "see also" when no such entry exists, and the Citizen Kane comment is debatable and not really relevant. I also rewrote the "highly dubious" part into a separate sentence.

I wanted to ask you what you mean by "distort, swap or misrepresent a MacGuffin." Any examples of films that do that?


Wee Jock MacGuffin

Post 2

anachromaticeye

Hi Bagpuss!



I've made a few changes here A45877693 that might help. smiley - smiley


Wee Jock MacGuffin

Post 3

Bagpuss

Sorry, I'm back looking at this again now. I looked through your new version and I see you expanded on the "misrepresent" thing. Anything else I should know about? I'll send this in soon if it's okay with you.


Wee Jock MacGuffin

Post 4

anachromaticeye

Yeah send it off if you think it's ready. It wasn't in peer review very long. I think there may have been some novice scouting involved. Not sure.

I like the link to the northern gannets. You don't mean us though d'ya?


Wee Jock MacGuffin

Post 5

Bagpuss

Okay, I'm not sure what to say. If you want to work more at the article I'm sure I can get it de-picked. Otherwise, having checked for any glaring errors I should send it in.


Wee Jock MacGuffin

Post 6

Bagpuss

So, shall I send the article in?


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for anachromaticeye

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more