A Conversation for The Alternative Writing Workshop

A25709934 - chapter one

Post 1

ianhimself

Entry: chapter one - A25709934
Author: ianhimself - U5477852

i don't know about this. maybe it will get into chapter two....maybe it won't... time... i guess, will tell... to those of you who read my ramblings and respond with such kindness ... thank you


A25709934 - chapter one

Post 2

U1250369


Ian, that was such an interesting and absorbing read. A love story with bite.

Not sure that you need a second chapter. Chapter one was complete.

Do you have a penchant for red-heads smiley - winkeye


A25709934 - chapter one

Post 3

ianhimself

indubitably .....

smiley - winkeye


A25709934 - chapter one

Post 4

minorvogonpoet

This is an excellent start, if you wanted to write something longer. It introduces both Peter and Rebecca as sympathetic characters, and establishes Peter's predicament. As always with your pieces, it's beautifully written. smiley - smiley

The trouble with this story is that it's not exactly original. So, if you wanted to write a novel starting like this and submit it for publication, how do you make it sufficiently different to attract attention?


A25709934 - chapter one

Post 5

tartaronne

Enjoyed reading the first chapter. Waits for the second.

smiley - smiley


A25709934 - chapter one

Post 6

ianhimself

to minor V....i agree totally. this is one of three novels i've played around with....and its lack of originality does bore me a little. I have one almost finished now - more off the wall... and definitely original. It won't pass the censors here though!

smiley - wah


A25709934 - chapter one

Post 7

Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor

The basic conceit is interesting, but I find the opening over-written. And using 'transference' twice in one chapter jarred, for some reason.

The emotions are universal, which needs more selling than something startling.

I think what I'm missing here is a voice. The narrator is wavering between flip and poetic - good deal. But it needs a more crisp approach to keep my head from spinning. I feel like I'm working too hard.

Could you tell me why I'm supposed to care about this guy, other than that he's breathing?

Loved the sentence: 'She walked into it like a stalked wildcat approaching a tethered goat.'smiley - ok


A25709934 - chapter one

Post 8

ianhimself

ah you know, i pretty much agree with all of those points.....i played around with the story for months, not because i wanted to, but largely because i couldn't think of a lot else to write about...then i abandoned it fo awhile ... and stuck chapter one on here a few weeks ago just to make sure that i had been right in my abandoning!

thanks guys......the verdict was deliverred with much kindness....

smiley - cheers


A25709934 - chapter one

Post 9

ianhimself

ps, i know how to spell "delivered"...i just can't type


Key: Complain about this post