A Conversation for The Alternative Writing Workshop

A6162437 - The Flame

Post 1

David B - Singing Librarian Owl

Entry: The Flame - A6162437
Author: David B, Singing Librarian Owl - U201818

A poem I wrote when struggling with clinical depression. I came across this in my room recently and gave it a bit of a polish before posting it here.

David


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 2

U1250369

I enjoyed it very much. Thank you.

Would be great to see the poem picked up by the powers that be and shown in The Post


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 3

frontiersman

Good Afternoon David,

I like this short poem. The flame is full of early pride and optimism of its power and brightness, which gives way to a later atmosphere of fear and doubt of its power to continue the struggle and about its own ability to avoid extinction. It stands alone, without help or shelter in the struggles of its life. It prevails in its quest for survival, saying that it must never be extinguished.
I feel that the last verse gives the impression that the life of the flame is infinite. But an end must ultimately come to everything, however important it may seem to itself, and to others, that it should survive. But I see the reason for that optimism as a metaphor for continuing life and recovery from trauma. The ultimate end postponed.

I see the poem in the context of the illness you were personally struggling with at the time of its composition. As a kind of allegory, ending with your full recovery and leaving you with a healthy optimism towards life and all that it offers.

Is my response 'eyewash'? Well, maybe!


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 4

U1250369

Now why couldn't I have said thatsmiley - laugh


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 5

frontiersman

Well Chips, you could very well have said that!

I've seen your responses to other poems and postings that tell me you can if you choose to do so!

Anyway Chips, what I have said might be regarded and rejected by others with disdain!

Ronsmiley - biggrin


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 6

U1250369

That's their problem if they wish to reject your opinions with disdain

Sometimes I feel an urge to write a World and Peace critique, but, mostly, I can't be M@C&Ad smiley - blush


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 7

David B - Singing Librarian Owl

Thanks for the comments. Regarding the final line, do you think it would be better if I said 'not' instead of 'never'?


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 8

U1250369

I would have said 'the flame will never die'

And sorry, I think you meant to type 'nursing'...


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 9

frontiersman

Well, you're not alone there!

I, too, very often can't be a..ed to write at length!

Largely depends on how I feel emotionally and physically at the time, as to whether I go ahead and respond.


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 10

U1250369

I seesmiley - cool


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 11

frontiersman

You see Chips, I didn't notice that tiny error; but you did!
None of us are infallible!


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 12

David B - Singing Librarian Owl

I wonder what 'nuesing' means... Well spotted. smiley - smiley


A6162437 - The Flame

Post 13

U1250369

Now I feel a nit pickersmiley - laugh

And,if you are going to criticise, always start and finish on a good note




A6162437 - The Flame

Post 14

J

Strong metaphor. In my mind's eye, the flame got smaller and smaller, was pushed to the edge and was dying, but was *rescued* by that last stanza.

It always is incredible to me when someone chooses to open a personal piece like this up. I couldn't do it. smiley - smiley

smiley - blacksheep


Key: Complain about this post