A Conversation for Trepanning

Heightened Intelligence

Post 1

§hadow

There are also those who believe that the additional oxygen to the brain causes heightened intelligence and can be done to increase their IQ.
~S smiley - smiley


Pain

Post 2

Aurora

The trepanning done thousands of years ago must have been incredibly painful, with no anaesthetic available!

Also, from a book "The Subtle Knife" by Philip Pullman (and I don't know how true this is in reality), shamans used trepanning to let the gods into their heads. Was this done in real life?


Pain

Post 3

Gnomon - time to move on

How do you know they had no anaesthetics?


Pain

Post 4

Aurora

How do you know they did?

~~A~~


Pain

Post 5

jqr

Forget the anaesthesia, what I want to know is, if I cut a hole in my head, will the gods *really* come in? smiley - smiley


Pain

Post 6

Aurora

I wouldn't try it smiley - smiley

~~A~~


Pain

Post 7

The Apprentice

And, obviously, you're going to be doing more drilling than cutting. There's a fair amount of solid bone to handle. Re. the early point about shaman's use of the technic to 'allow the gods in' we can only guess. Prehistory is an awful pain to pin facts to.


Pain

Post 8

Aurora

And I'm not any kind of historian...

~~A~~


Pain

Post 9

Gonzo

Like the article. For more info, there was an article in New Scientist about trepanning a couple of weeks ago (16th or possibly 9th Sept).
The Incas were the experts, and their main motivation was medical. Archaeoloists have found that something like 50% of all adult male Inca skeletons had sustained head wounds, due probably to the clubs and sling-shots they employed in their frequent raids on each other's villages. BAttlefield brain surgery arose through expediency.
Researchers have traced the development of techniques through Inca history, from crude rectangular holes, through scraping and paring, to neat circles of drilled holes from which the central section would be removed.
They probably did have anaesthetics and certainly antiseptic balms to aid healing.
It's also interesting that in C14th Peru, the survival rate following these operations was about 80%, compared to 25% in C19th Europe.

As far as oxygen-highs or whatever, one skull was found with 7 neat, partially healed holes. The researchers believe this must have been because the individual had developed a liking for the operation and had deliberately requested it.(!)


Pain

Post 10

Aurora

Liking? Wow!

~~A~~


Pain

Post 11

Gonzo

Hey kids! Why not try it yourself by sellotaping a pastry cutter to your head and doing a headstand for as long as you can!
smiley - bigeyes


Pain

Post 12

The Apprentice

I wouldn't recommend the pastry-cutter. Some a little sharper. A DeWalt drill bit, perhaps. One of those wood working tools you use to make little holes. A bradawl? Can't remember.


Pain

Post 13

Aurora

A corkscrew perhaps.

~~A~~


Pain

Post 14

The Apprentice

Really it needs to be something that you can smack through the skull with a single strike or push. A drill is bad enough, but the combination of pressing and screwing means it's going to melt through the bone in no time. Something like a think pin or needle would be fine providing you could deliver a hefty blow to the end with a hammer or perhaps by smacking your head against a wall. I don't know. I think it's best to stay clear of the self-administered version and stick to finding a professional willing to complete the operation with a little more time, effort and suitable medicinal preparations.


Pain

Post 15

Aurora

So now we're trying to find the best place to get a hole drilled into your head. Fun.

~~A~~


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more