A Conversation for Organic Chemistry

Organic Chem -> Molecular Chem

Post 1

Hell

I understand that the subdivision into organic (i.e. originating from living stuff) and inorganic (the rest) chemistry is
an anachronism, that somehow managed to survive to this century. Modern scientists no longer use this subdivision.
As stated, silicon based compounds have been added to the "organic" chemistry domain. You can go farther and add
all kinds of compounds that build covalent molecules (NOT solids, salts, complexes...) to that domain. Instead you
add the "classic" carbon-based "organic" chemistry to this new (bigger) group, and call it molecular or molecule chemistry.

This process (i.e. the new subdivision) has not yet been fully finished.

Somehow I'd like this information to be included in the "topic".

Greetings,

HELL


Organic Chem -> Molecular Chem

Post 2

Researcher 170621

Actually we still do have separate inorganic and organic departments although the edhges are blurred.


Organic Chem -> Molecular Chem

Post 3

Orcus

Yeah we do. I still think of myself as an Organic chemist but my boss likes calling us "chemical biologists" or some other trendy word to make it sound more modern and appealing.


Organic Chem -> Molecular Chem

Post 4

EwenMc

Nice try, but you can't distinguish between molecules and salts consistently: Who gets sodium methanoate - is it the same category as methanoic acid or does it go with sodium hydrogencarbonate? I guess that although the categories are useful they do look silly close up.

As for the old meaning of organic as 'living' I must mention the Journal of Inorganic Biochemistry - what would the first chemists have made of that?


Organic Chem -> Molecular Chem

Post 5

Dr Hell

smiley - winkeye


Organic Chem -> Molecular Chem

Post 6

Apollyon - Grammar Fascist

"I still think of myself as an Organic chemist but my boss likes calling us "chemical biologists""

So what about biochemists, eh?


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more