h2g2 The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy: Earth Edition

Entry: Pokemon Emerald Walkthrough IV (Dewford) - A45633864
Author: interspark - U13716911

Just moved from Peer Review.

Half of this series was sent Back to Entry, the others went to Flea Market.

A44177934  Pokemon Emerald Walkthrough I 
A44241211  Pokemon Emerald Walkthrough II (Petalburg to Rusboro)  
A44367429  Pokemon Emerald Walkthrough III (Rusturf Tunnel to Dewford)
A45633864  Pokemon Emerald Walkthrough IV (Dewford) 
A45970112  Pokemon Emerald Walkthrough V (Slateport)
A46235423  Pokemon Emerald Walkthrough VI (cycling road)
A48973422  Pokemon Emerald Walkthrough VII (Mauville)

I would like to propose Back to Entry for the entire series.
Although Games Reviews can indeed contain helpful hints, tips and cheats - possibly even a guide to particularly difficult sections - this should be in balance to actual substance and a review of the game as a whole, not a complete dot-to-dot of go here, go there, do that.

These articles in my view are pure walkthroughs and thus unsuitable for the edited guide as they stand.

The Guide definitely could do with an article on Pokemon, though. I think a more review approach would be in order and would work better. What I do like about this series is the enthusiasm for the subject that shines through. I'd love to read an article by the same author in which they write a review and say more about the appeal of the game, its game play, how well it has dated etc.

I don't think these articles are suitable for the guide as they stand, but I do see potential from the author.

<BB<