Semmelweis Reflex: a human behavioral tendency to stick to preexisting beliefs and to reject fresh ideas that contradict them (despite adequate evidence).
– Gupta, VK et al., 'Semmelweis Reflex: An Age-Old Prejudice', World Neurosurg. 2019 Dec 16. pii: S1878-8750(19)33040-2
Semmelweis Reflex: Mob behavior found among primates and larval hominids on undeveloped planets, in which a discovery of important scientific fact is punished rather than rewarded.
– Timothy Leary and Robert Anton Wilson, The Game of Life, p 43
Let us sing the praises of Ignaz Semmelweis (1818-1865), the Hungarian physician and martyr who saved countless lives by persistently insisting, against overwhelming medical opposition, that it might be a good idea for doctors to wash their hands after handling corpses and before touching pregnant women. This first happened in 1847. Look at that date again, whenever you begin to feel complacent about humans and their devotion to science. A quick look at what Dr Semmelweis was up against, and what happened to him, tells us a lot about our scientific knowledge and how it advances.
What Happened in Vienna
In 1846, Ignaz Semmelweis from Budapest became a medical resident at the First Obstetrical Clinic in Vienna. The clinic offered free medical care to pregnant women. In return, the women agreed to be studied, which meant that if they died, the medical students could do autopsies. The medical students got to do a lot more autopsies than you'd think: 10% of the women who gave birth at the clinic died. The doctors called what they died of 'puerperal fever': a disease related to childbirth. They had a lot of theories about this disease – we'll get to that in a minute – but the basic conclusion was, 'Childbirth is really dangerous. Thank God we aren't women.'
Dr Semmelweis wasn't content with this explanation. He had the strange notion that science was not a body of lore to be memorised, but a method for answering questions. Questions like, 'Why do 10% of the mothers in the First Clinic die, but only 4% or less in the Second Clinic?' Here was some of his reasoning:
- The First Clinic is staffed by doctors and medical students, all educated men. The Second Clinic is staffed by female midwives, not nearly as educated. It is unlikely those women know something we don't.
- You would think that overcrowding would raise the death rate. But no: The Second Clinic is much more crowded than the First Clinic. That is because word has got around that the First Clinic is a death trap. Women will actually give birth in the street rather than undergo labour in the First Clinic. And the rate of puerperal fever from giving birth on the streets of Vienna is actually lower than the death rate in my clinic. This is strange.
- I've eliminated all the other variables – even religion! The only real difference between the two clinics is who works there: medical students versus midwives. What gives?
The main difference between the work of the medical students and the midwives, Semmelweis found, was that the midwives weren't performing autopsies. But how could that be it? Semmelweis worried over all these deaths – so much so that he became seriously depressed.
The breakthrough came in a sad form: Semmelweis' colleague, professor of forensic medicine Jakob Kolletschka, was directing an autopsy performed by a student. The student's hand slipped and cut Kolletschka's finger with the scalpel he was using. Kolletschka died shortly after the accident, of an impressive array of quite deadly diseases: bilateral pleurisy, pericarditis, peritonitis, and meningitis. Surprisingly, after studying the body, Semmelweis concluded that Kolletschka had died of the same thing his maternity patients were dying of, and which they were calling 'puerperal fever'.
Semmelweis proposed that there was a connection between contamination with cadavers and puerperal fever. The connection appeared to be medical students. Was it possible that something was getting transferred from those dead bodies to the live patients, and making them sick? Pish and tosh, said the medical world. That is unscientific nonsense, and probably a conspiracy theory. Who ever heard of invisible 'somethings' getting transferred between bodies?
Disease Theory in 1847
In 1847, European and North American medicine knew nothing of germs. Bacteria and viruses would have been regarded as science fiction. So how did they think disease was spread? Here is what a doctor wrote around 50 years later:
It was believed by many that with a certain intensity and extension of the malady a contagion was brought into existence. According to this belief a contagion represented a specific virus which originated only in the diseased organism and that from that point of origin could produce in another individual the same disease. In some minds the contagion assumed the form of a mysterious halo, or areola, which clung to the unfortunate practitioner who had come under its malign influence and rendered him a source of danger wherever he went. Coming near to the time when the doctrine of Semmelweis was announced we find an almost general prevalence of the belief that the pregnant and puerperal woman was a thing unique in nature.
– Richard Cole Newton, A Brief Study of the Contribution of Ignaz Philip Semmelweis to Modern Medicine, p 9.
In other words, disease was a sort of 'aura' that got passed around. This sounds rather supernatural to a modern ear. Be that as it may, the medical profession flatly refused to believe Semmelweis. It was absolutely not possible for a gentleman's hands to be dirty enough to infect a pregnant woman. Particularly not a lower-class pregnant woman.
What Happened Next?
- Semmelweis forced all the medical students to wash their hands.
- The death rate in the First Clinic in Vienna dropped to almost nothing. In fact, there were two months in 1848 when nobody died having babies at all.
- Semmelweis explained his theory to everyone who would listen, including the Vienna Medical Society, who elected him a member. He didn't know what was getting transferred – they didn't know anything about bacteria – but he had experimentally determined that hand-washing worked.
- Semmelweis' prophylaxis made a number of people angry: the nobility, many doctors at the Vienna hospital, the clergy, for some obscure reason...the list went on. They campaigned against Semmelweis, and maligned him personally.
- Semmelweis was fired from his job in Vienna. He had to move back to Budapest.
- Semmelweis wouldn't give up the fight for hand-washing. He was passionate. He called doctors who didn't wash their hands 'murderers'. He became severely depressed.
- Whether because of his severe depression or for other reasons (early-onset Alzheimer's?), Semmelweis behaved so erratically that his wife agreed to have him committed to an asylum.
- Semmelweis died 14 days later – of an improperly treated infection. Apparently, nobody washed their hands.
Honour Dr Semmelweis: Wash Your Hands!
The soap dissolves the fat membrane and the virus falls apart like a house of cards and 'dies', or rather, we should say it becomes inactive as viruses aren't really alive.
– Icelandic chemist Palli Thordarson on Twitter, on why soap and water kill viruses
Dr Richard Cole Newton (1851-1919) wrote a pamphlet about Semmelweis in 1910. He concluded that 'Semmelweis’s interpretation of this phenomenon was as truly a scientific triumph as Newton’s interpretation of the phenomenon of the falling apple.' He also noted, as other biographers of the pioneer have, that Semmelweis might not have figured it out if he hadn't been such a good-hearted person. 'In A Brief Study of the Contribution of Ignaz Philip Semmelweis to Modern Medicine, he writes: 'Had his pity not been stirred by the unfortunate women condemned to suffering and death while paying to nature the sacred debt of perpetuating their species, probably his great discovery would never have been made.'
Maybe what scientific progress needs is less prejudiced thinking, the patience to study a phenomenon, and enough heart to care about a problem in the first place. In the meantime, wash your hands, with soap, for at least 20 seconds, to prevent the spread of bacteria and viruses. And bless the memory of Dr Semmelweis when you do.