A Conversation for The Scouts' Home Page
Exceptions to Peer Review
Martin Harper Started conversation May 23, 2001
The yahoo poll is dumb because it doesn't deal with people who vote for more than one choice properly, ho hum. Thanks to the twelve people who voted 
Unsurprisingly, us Scouts appear to be in favour of peer review applying to most things, except the "this weeks topic" stuff. Current events and special priviledges are the other two fairly well-supported exceptions, with just under half of us supporting each one.
If anyone wants to comment or ague their corner, please do so...
Yahoo! Groups Notification wrote:
> The following h2g2Scouts poll is now closed. Here are the
> final results:
>
> POLL QUESTION: What exceptions should be made to Peer
> Review - which categories of entry
> should be able to enter the guide
> without going through PR?
>
> CHOICES AND RESULTS
> - Entries written by the h2g2 medical/legal/whatever team., 2 votes, 17%
> - Entries written by members of the h2g2 team., 2 votes, 17%
> - High Quality Entries., 1 votes, 8%
> - Entries which are too specialised to gain from Peer Review., 1 votes, 8%
> - Entries created from 'This Weeks Topic', 11 votes, 92%
> - Entries which are about current events., 5 votes, 42%
> - Entries written by particularly good writers who have gained special privileges., 4 votes, 33%
> - All Other Entries, 0 votes, 0%
> - NO exceptions, 0 votes, 0%
Key: Complain about this post
Exceptions to Peer Review
More Conversations for The Scouts' Home Page
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."