A Conversation for Trotter's Curse
- 1
- 2
PLEASE REVIEW -Trotter's Curse
The Wisest Fool Posted Nov 12, 1999
Pretty spooky stuff and an interesting story. Bit of an 18th Century X-File, perhaps. It's good and the linked articles are even better. Whether you could get all of them accepted is a moot point, but it's nice to have some background for anyone visiting Pennsylvania, which is after all the home of the Monty Burns vampire!?!
One thing - the 'curse' said "May another take his office", but the incumbent governor won, so it wasn't Wayne's office to lose. Still, why pick holes in a good curse?
PLEASE REVIEW -Trotter's Curse
Jimi X Posted Nov 14, 1999
This state if full of spooky tales like this! And if you're into it, it's pretty easy to find out hundred of good ones when you work in the newspaper biz.
Glad you liked it! Odd that bit about "another taking his office" I never really thought about it. That was always mentioned as part of the curse and I haven't heard of anybody pointing out that little tidbit before! Good catch!!
PLEASE REVIEW -Trotter's Curse
Bruce Posted Nov 15, 1999
I don't think the 1st paragraph works - it sort of drops you in the middle of something without explaining what.
Maybe, if you included a reference to Trotters curse & then started explaining the background of who & when etc it would work better.
I enjoyed it though.
;^)#
PLEASE REVIEW -Trotter's Curse
kats-eyes (psychically confirmed caffeine addict) Posted Nov 17, 1999
what is there to say? great - I love those spooky tales... only two very tiny things worth mentioning:
"...Capt. William Elliott, Robert Hunter and John Horrell..." -> I don't get whether all of them were Captains or only Elliot, but I don't know the abbreviation for the plural, maybe it's the same...just because you mentioned three officers...
and I think the reference to your article about Mad Anthony is a bit hard to find in the footnote, if you'd bring it in that sentence about his share of the course, it would stimulate readers to go on and find out why he was buried in different graves...
just my humble opinion though.
I'll refrain from rating, cause I'm not quite sure of the system (1 lowest, 10 highest is it?), but I do think it's worth to be approved right away
Please Review - Trotter's Curse
Courtesy38 Posted Nov 19, 1999
Great posting. I love the break down of the curse and what happened to each individual.
It reminds me of the curse that the Head of the Knights Templar gave before being burned at the stake. He cursed the Pope and Emperor to stand before God and explain themselves within the year. Before the year was out, both Pope and Emperor died.
Anyhoo ... I give it a 9.
Courtesy
Please Review - Trotter's Curse
Jimi X Posted Nov 21, 1999
Was that Templar curse before or after some snuck away in a hay cart to found the Masons in Scotland?
Anyway, thanks for the read and the review....
Lots of Templar stuff on h2g2 lately! (is this a Y2K thing?)
PLEASE REVIEW -Trotter's Curse
PenGwen: Benevolent Tyrant of Hebetude and Vivacity, Keeper of the Wonder Book of Useless Knowledge Posted Jan 10, 2000
Well, I feel like I want more. While you told what happened to each individual, I really want to know why Wayne's body was taken apart and reburried in different graves. An 'in conclusion' paragraph would tidy it all up a bit.
Also the first paragraph starts out about Trotter, and ends up being about Wayne, which is a little confusing. Perhaps a paragraph about each of them would help.
Key: Complain about this post
- 1
- 2
PLEASE REVIEW -Trotter's Curse
- 21: The Wisest Fool (Nov 12, 1999)
- 22: Jimi X (Nov 14, 1999)
- 23: Bruce (Nov 15, 1999)
- 24: Jimi X (Nov 15, 1999)
- 25: kats-eyes (psychically confirmed caffeine addict) (Nov 17, 1999)
- 26: Jimi X (Nov 17, 1999)
- 27: Courtesy38 (Nov 19, 1999)
- 28: Jimi X (Nov 21, 1999)
- 29: PenGwen: Benevolent Tyrant of Hebetude and Vivacity, Keeper of the Wonder Book of Useless Knowledge (Jan 10, 2000)
More Conversations for Trotter's Curse
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."