A Conversation for The Bookworms Club Weekly Book Review
The Cloud Garden
JulesK Started conversation Apr 17, 2004
Hope this is the kind of thing. Was unsure whether this was too close to the bone given current events in Iraq but I only read it last week so it was uppermost in my mind. Feel free to keep it on ice until a later date.
Jules
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The Cloud Garden
By Tom Hart Dyke and Paul Winder
In 2000, these British men, who’d met when travelling separately around South America, decided to try to cross the Darien Gap (an area of land linking North and South America). The area was rife with paramilitaries and guerrillas and tourists were advised to steer well clear.
Paul, 29 at the time, was the adventurous type and believed that he was up to the challenge. Tom, six years his junior, was travelling in order to search out rare orchids and was keen to add to his findings.
They hired a local guide and travelled for six days with no incident. Just as they were about to reach the Colombian border, they were ambushed and taken hostage by an unknown group. Their guides disappeared. For the next nine months they were forced to travel around the area with the armed group, whose members came and went.
The book describes their ordeal and experiences and tells the tale of how they returned safely home, which itself contains a surreal twist.
The narrative is shared between the two men, who pull no punches in the description of their feelings, both towards each other and their captors, during this time. Both tell their stories with a dry humour and the reader is surprised to find themselves laughing out loud at incidents which happened in the depths of a fearsome journey. The characters within the armed group are described in detail; some are frightening, others frankly comical. The pair are well aware of how surreal and yet painfully real their experiences are.
Once started, this book is difficult to put down. It gives an insight to a subject which is highly topical and poignant at this moment in time. Given that they were travellers and not writers in search of a story, both men’s stories read well and complement each other.
The Cloud Garden
Z Posted Apr 17, 2004
No topical is good! We like topical!...
Excellent review, I did wonder why it was called 'The Cloud Garden' though... I do want to read the book now.
The Cloud Garden
JulesK Posted Apr 17, 2004
The origin of the title seems to have been left to the reader's interpretation (unless I am especially dense) - it could relate to the general high-level terrain they were living in (linked to Tom's love of orchids) or to a specific garden actually created by Tom while in captivity. Or both. Have had a flick through and can't find it specified.
The Cloud Garden
Z Posted Apr 17, 2004
Oh right, - that makes sense. It just seemed to be a bit of an airy fairy title for a book written by two guys.
Thanks for the review, and I'll definately look it up soon
The Cloud Garden
Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat Posted Apr 22, 2004
Brilliant! *does a happy little dance that she doesn't have to do work*
The Cloud Garden
JulesK Posted Apr 22, 2004
Glad you approve.
I'm sure your 'to do' list is longer than one item, though - otherwise we all want your job !
Jules
The Cloud Garden
Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat Posted Apr 24, 2004
Um, let's see?
*has a think*
Read all new bookworm threads. If they are sign-up requests, welcome new member and add researcher number to main bookworm page.
If they are reviews, tell researcher how brilliant they are, then, on appropriate day, delete old review from Rough Writing page and copy and paste new one, making small editing changes if necessary to grammar. Or, if no review is available, dredge own memory and write one myself. Change author on Rough Writing page. E-mail Shazz to tell her that review is ready, and who wrote it. This happens once a week.
When new edition of Post is out, read through review again in its full glory, and subscribe to the page to recieve any convo's on that review.
This is quite time-consuming...
The Cloud Garden
Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat Posted Apr 24, 2004
Just realised, I saw those blokes on This Morning...
The Cloud Garden
JulesK Posted Apr 24, 2004
Yep, me too - I didn't realise at first but there's a key event that was well-publicised, so then I joined the dots in my memory (haven't put it in the review so as not to spoil it for those who don't watch daytime telly!)
The Cloud Garden
Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat Posted Apr 27, 2004
Would that be the thing with the people that they gave funny nicknames too?
The Cloud Garden
JulesK Posted Apr 27, 2004
Well they did give them nicknames but that wasn't the key 'odd' event which happened, no.
The Cloud Garden
Z Posted Apr 28, 2004
PP you do a simply marvellous job - and now I have to get hold of this book. Honestly you'd think being stuck on the Outer hebrides I'd have time to read, but It seems I've acquired a life up here!
The Cloud Garden
JulesK Posted Apr 28, 2004
Gosh, lots of walks and nature-type stuff up there, then? And serious weather!
The Cloud Garden
Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat Posted May 7, 2004
*PP's head grows considerably larger and bangs into the gentleman on the computer next door*
The Cloud Garden
Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat Posted May 14, 2004
He was quite an elderly gentleman, I think I probably would have just frightened him!
Key: Complain about this post
The Cloud Garden
- 1: JulesK (Apr 17, 2004)
- 2: Z (Apr 17, 2004)
- 3: JulesK (Apr 17, 2004)
- 4: Z (Apr 17, 2004)
- 5: Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat (Apr 22, 2004)
- 6: JulesK (Apr 22, 2004)
- 7: Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat (Apr 24, 2004)
- 8: Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat (Apr 24, 2004)
- 9: JulesK (Apr 24, 2004)
- 10: Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat (Apr 27, 2004)
- 11: JulesK (Apr 27, 2004)
- 12: Z (Apr 28, 2004)
- 13: JulesK (Apr 28, 2004)
- 14: Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat (May 7, 2004)
- 15: JulesK (May 7, 2004)
- 16: Pinwheel Pearl, GURU, Post Book Reviewer, Muse of Japanese Maples and Owlatron's Thundercat (May 14, 2004)
More Conversations for The Bookworms Club Weekly Book Review
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."