A Conversation for 'The Glass Is Half Full' - Good or Bad?

One of the statements is impossible!

Post 1

Yeliab {h2g2as}

Can someone please explain just HOW something, anything, can be /HALF/ empty.

Lets look at this:-
Half means the said unity divided by 2, making two equal portions of the initial quantity, ie 50% of it. So half a cake is only 50% of the cake that was. Half a thousand pounds means you only have £500 left and your now wondering just how you spent that last 500!smiley - erm

Empty - null, non existant mater, none, run out, lacking of liquid, 100% not there, not a lot, less than not a lot.....smiley - erm

So... if we have 'half empty' it means we have 50% of nothing, which is (what ever way you calculate it) still nothing. Therefore a glass that is 'half emply' is in fact empty.smiley - winkeye

Therefore the two statements under disscussion are refering to two completely un-compairable situations.smiley - biggrin

Yeliab
smiley - cool



One of the statements is impossible!

Post 2

Not Shakespeare

A glass containing nothing is empty.

If one half of the glass in question contains nothing, that half of the glass is empty. However, people are sloppy and tend to say "the glass is half empty" instead of "half of the glass is empty"

Alternately, the phrase "1/2 empty" is a description of the cup's potentional to be full.


One of the statements is impossible!

Post 3

Fizzicist

Either way the glass is exactly twice as big as it needs to be at that moment in the time space continuinuinuinuinum! smiley - tongueout


One of the statements is impossible!

Post 4

Amanda

Unless its an oversize glass to allow for a head on a beer! smiley - smiley


One of the statements is impossible!

Post 5

Yeliab {h2g2as}

smiley - run


One of the statements is impossible!

Post 6

Amanda

smiley - laugh


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more