This is the Message Centre for Pastey

Facts, Damn Facts, and Biased Facts

Post 21

Icy North

I wasn't aware of that delusion earlier. I just remember you being active in Peer Review. You wrote an entry about your college marching band, iirc.

Facts, Damn Facts, and Biased Facts

Post 22


Icy, this conversation isn't about me, and I'm not at all interested in talking about me, but you seem to be, so I'll unsub.

Facts, Damn Facts, and Biased Facts

Post 23

Dmitri Gheorgheni - Not Banned in China

HN and Icy, you brought up an interesting point about entries, if I may...

Who should write about what?

Now, I agree with HN that you don't have to be a certified expert in a subject to tackle it. But I think your background affects what aspect of the topic you want to approach.

Example: I was a menace in the chemistry lab, and the despair of my proifessors. But I write about patent medicines, say. When I do, I'm not really interested in the chemistry - and I'd leave the statistical analysis to our real experts, like Woolly Mammoth. smiley - winkeye

I write about the social and historical aspects of the patent medicine phenomenon. That's something I know how to research.

Maybe, if you want to have an entry on placebos, you either let a couple of people tackle it together, based on what they like to research, or...

Let different people write different entries about different aspects of the phenomenon. Such as, 'the medical verdict on placebos', 'placebos in popular advertising', 'the history of placebos', etc? smiley - bigeyes

Facts, Damn Facts, and Biased Facts

Post 24

Icy North

Yes, I agree that anyone can research and write about any subject. I'm certainly no expert in most of the entries I've written. It's the purpose of Peer Review to assure the entry's quality.

Sadly, Peer Review is also suffering as participation wanes. The sooner we get the site relaunched the better.

Facts, Damn Facts, and Biased Facts

Post 25


You could pop over and comment on my Mass Run entry smiley - winkeye

Facts, Damn Facts, and Biased Facts

Post 26

Nosebagbadger {Ace}

And and excellent entry it was too! smiley - smiley

Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for Pastey

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more