A Conversation for What is God?
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
azahar Posted Feb 18, 2004
Yes, blicky, perhaps you should!
Androcles and the lino???
*wipes tears of laughter from eyes*
Thanks honey, I needed that.
az
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
DA ; Simply Vicky: Don't get pithy with me! Posted Feb 18, 2004
<<(although I have heard that Christianity sometimes finds it hard to get a look in),>>
So. Why am I not surprised?
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
Fathom Posted Feb 19, 2004
Hi az,
You didn't read 'Androcles and the lino' at school? One of a series of classic Greek texts along with 'Perseus and the vinyl tiles' and 'Jason and the Axminster'.
F
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
Alan M6791 Posted Feb 19, 2004
'It's a Greek legend'!!! Written by George Bernard Shaw adapted from an Aesop fable. Aesop was a slave in ancient Greece, born 600 B.C.
Alji
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
DA ; Simply Vicky: Don't get pithy with me! Posted Feb 19, 2004
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
badger party tony party green party Posted Feb 20, 2004
'It's a Greek legend'!!!
Yeah I know that now. My point was and still is that I and other children were told that story as something that supports the power of faith in the the bigG.
I dont care if its a greek or roman story at all but thats not the point. I was trying to show how religious types use stories that arent true to indoctrinate the young.
one love
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
pikin42 Posted Feb 20, 2004
Hmm thats strange... I don't ever remember being told "Christian" stories except ones from the Bible!
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
Noggin the Nog Posted Feb 20, 2004
More important than the truth or falsity of individual stories (arguably) are the traditional interpretations and ways of reading those stories. When I was young I remember stories of the life of Jesus as a sugar coated pastoral idyll. That was the way the stories were traditionally told. Yet it now seems pretty clear that it wasn't like that, and that the ministry was conducted in a context of political and religious tension bordering on rebellion, which makes a difference to the reading of verses like "I come not to bring peace, but a sword."
Noggin
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
pikin42 Posted Feb 20, 2004
Not really. I remember doing St George and the dragon several times, but since no child over the age of about 5 seriously believes dragons existed I only ever remember being taught about it in the same way as when we were taught about Greek myths or King Author, only with a slightly more patriotic spin!
And your right, Noggin, children's teaching of the Bible etc does tend to be rather selective, but only in that it doesn't go into the areas they are unlikely to be able to understand at that age!
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
badger party tony party green party Posted Feb 20, 2004
Well Pikin we were at my school and the fact that even at your school those with an agenda were able to put a patriotic spin on a middle easter or possibly African man allegedly killing a mythical animal says a lot about the mindset of people who tell us that whats in the bible is true doent it?
one love
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
pikin42 Posted Feb 21, 2004
Since my school didn't promote the Bible as true... (in fact my younger brother once got very confused when I had to point out quite gently why we didn't celebrate Divalli at home!)
Besides these stories arn't Christian ones. Although they may arise out of a Christian culture, the two things arn't the same!
Key: Complain about this post
Arguments for disbelief - subset Christians
- 461: badger party tony party green party (Feb 18, 2004)
- 462: badger party tony party green party (Feb 18, 2004)
- 463: azahar (Feb 18, 2004)
- 464: DA ; Simply Vicky: Don't get pithy with me! (Feb 18, 2004)
- 465: Fathom (Feb 19, 2004)
- 466: Alan M6791 (Feb 19, 2004)
- 467: DA ; Simply Vicky: Don't get pithy with me! (Feb 19, 2004)
- 468: badger party tony party green party (Feb 20, 2004)
- 469: pikin42 (Feb 20, 2004)
- 470: Noggin the Nog (Feb 20, 2004)
- 471: badger party tony party green party (Feb 20, 2004)
- 472: pikin42 (Feb 20, 2004)
- 473: badger party tony party green party (Feb 20, 2004)
- 474: pikin42 (Feb 21, 2004)
More Conversations for What is God?
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."