A Conversation for Stellar Magnitudes

A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 1

J'au-æmne

Jimi X (U53353) and I both thought this subject was wothy of a guide entry... so we both wrote one.
We'd like for them to be combined, please, together they make a good overview of a potentially confusing subject.


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 2

spoon

Indeed, they do. very well explained, I think.
Considering the complicated subject, it certainly'd be helpful for the reader to divide the whole article with the help of or . Yes, a bit more structure, that would be nice.

p.s. how come you know about this stuff? are you hobby-astronomers? or are you making money out of it?


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 3

spoon

-oops, no chatting. ts ts ts. (mh)


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 4

J'au-æmne

I'm studying Physics and Astronomy... I have to study these things. smiley - smiley


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 5

Sniggly - Researcher 146370

Agreed - combined they would make an excellent piece.

Next the seasoned star traveller would like to see explained:

1) How your navigational computer identifies a star by its absorption spectrum.
2) How it compensates for red shift and what evasive action it takes when blue shift goes into ultra-violet.


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 6

Munchkin

Yep, bung 'em together. I like the little intro paragraph from JimiX, although the tables are possily a bit much


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 7

26199

I like the tables!

*shrug*

26199


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 8

Lentilla (Keeper of Non-Sequiturs)

Jimi X and Joanna - I'm pleased to inform you that both of your entries will be edited into one, and eventually included in the Edited Guide. Thank you both for your excellent articles! When it does get into the Edited Guide, you will receive an e-mail letting you know - but it'll take a while!

- Lentilla


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 9

Mark Moxon

Editorial Note: This thread has been moved out of the Peer Review forum because this entry has now been recommended for the Edited Guide.


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 10

J'au-æmne

So thats why I couldn't find it earlier smiley - smiley great!


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 11

Cefpret

A very nice article -- actually it made me find an error in one of mine.smiley - smiley Since you explain both absolute and relative magnitudes, why not add the formula connecting M, m and r? I can't remember it exactly but it wasn't too complicated and one of the most important equations of astronomy.


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 12

J'au-æmne

Do you mean the distance modulus thing? M-m=5logd-5 where d is distance? (or something...smiley - winkeye)


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 13

Cefpret

Well, I don't like this 'log d' thing because log can't cope with distances but only with simple numbers. I looked it up: M-m=-5log(r/10pc). Further advantage: r can have any unit here.


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 14

J'au-æmne

Sorry; my astrophys. course was a year ago (!) I don't really remember the formula properly...
I don't understand about what you mean about the distance, though...


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 15

Cefpret

I hope I understand your question correctly. The argument of the logarithm mustn't contain units. log 5pc is merely undefined. But you _can_ say log (5pc/10pc)=log 0.5. Mostly people say log without saying that has to be in parsec and that you have to throw away the parsec itself.


A302239/A398801 - Stellar Magnitudes

Post 16

J'au-æmne

Hmm... okay, I see your point, I think... I also think Im going to go and spend a bit of time with my astrophys. textbook; looks like I need to revise that course some.


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for Stellar Magnitudes

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more