A Conversation for 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Peer Review: A87860875 - Desert Bus for Hope

Post 1

AlexAshman

Entry: Desert Bus for Hope - A87860875
Author: AlexAshman - U566116


Hi folks! Guess what I'll be doing next month.

Alex smiley - smiley


A87860875 - Desert Bus for Hope

Post 2

bobstafford

smiley - ok


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 3

AlexAshman


Thanks Bob.

I've gone through the entry again and made various little improvements. I've tried to keep the length down, as otherwise it's tempting to start listing memes and in-jokes. If there's anything I haven't explained properly, or anything that needs more context, please do let me know.


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 4

Tavaron da Quirm - Arts Editor

That sounds like a really dreadful game!smiley - laugh I definitely see why it should be in the Guide.

Your first sentence immediately raises the question: who is Paul Saunders? Am I supposed to know him?
Maybe you can just say 'Internet comedian Paul Saunders'?

I know you link to the Child's Play Homepage, but I think nobody should be forced to click any links when reading an Entry, so please add one sentence to say what they do.

Do they take turns playing the game on one computer or are there several people playing 'against each other' (like who arrives first)?

And if I feel really bored and slightly suicidal, where would I be able to get that game?


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 5

Bluebottle

Good to see you writing again! A very enjoyable entry, short and sweet.

The only thing I wondered was whether Graham Stark was the same Graham Stark who was Peter Sellers' best mate in the RAF and later appeared in many of his films, including the 'Pink Panther' series. His 'That is not my smiley - dog' is still one of the greatest comedy momentssmiley - rofl.

I'm guessing probably not.

<BB<


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 6

AlexAshman


Thanks for the suggestions - I've made some changes.

The game was never released, but it's out there on the net to be downloaded.

The Canadian Graham Stark didn't appear in the Pink Panther films. I doubt anyone would confuse them, but I've added a footnote so that I can link to a certain project from this entry smiley - winkeye


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 7

AlexAshman


Any more suggestions folks?


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 8

Gnomon - time to move on

I admit I'm confused by this. What was the purpose of the original boring game? And why was it designed by wizards.


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 9

Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor

This is a great entry. smiley - smiley I find the original concept for the game quite amusing, too. The idea of playing a bus-driving game in real time...well, it's just so zen...

Good luck if you're doing this!


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 10

AlexAshman


Gnomon, the purpose of the game was exactly as stated - it was intended to be as inoffensive and dull as possible in order to show that the medium of video gaming is not automatically a bad influence on people.

Thanks DG, I am indeed volunteering with them this year. Should be interesting...


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 11

Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor

I found a video review of this game that you might like:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RFi2vcseEz8

I was curious to see the screen, etc. smiley - laugh

Warning: the player uses colourful language...


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 12

Tavaron da Quirm - Arts Editor

Oh, I love his reviews. Watched loads of them some months ago. smiley - laugh


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 13

Gnomon - time to move on

Maybe it's just me, but I think this would work better if it was split up into separate sections a bit more:

Introductory paragraph

The Desert Bus game

The Comedy Troupe

The Marathon

You could put headers on each section to make it clearer, but more importantly, try and keep each section to its topic. The information about Desert Bus should be moved from the introduction ino the Desert Bus section.

smiley - oksmiley - booksmiley - galaxy


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 14

Tavaron da Quirm - Arts Editor

I agree that this would be better.


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 15

AlexAshman


Ok, done. smiley - smiley


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 16

Gnomon - time to move on

Thanks Alex. I think that is a lot better.


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 17

AlexAshman


Only 11 days until Desert Bus 9 starts!

Any further thoughts on the entry? smiley - smiley


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 18

broelan

What an amazing story!

The entry looks fine as it stands, but since it's still here and pushing on mid-December, if the totals are available, would you like to update the 2014 results with the 2015 results? (and, for the record, I think "no" is a perfectly acceptable answer).


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 19

AlexAshman

Done smiley - smiley


A87860875 - 'Desert Bus for Hope' - Charity Video Gaming Marathon

Post 20

AlexAshman


smiley - whistle


Key: Complain about this post