Berthold Buttgereit and the Gender Police

1 Conversation

In many times and many places, the police or other security forces have been empowered by the law to arrest and punish people who are perceived to be wearing clothing of the 'opposite sex'. Germany in 1912 was no exception, but for Berthold Buttgereit and several other people, protection was offered by 'Transvestitenscheine' - 'transvestite passes'.

Against the Law

Laws designed to prevent people from stepping out of their place in society, laws designed to prevent people from concealing their identity, and even laws designed to prevent indecency or misdemeanour all had the consequence of causing people's gender to be scrutinised.

For example, Sumptuary Laws regulated what clothes people could wear so that they were not able to impersonate people with more power than them, which affected people wearing 'men's clothes' if they were not judged to look masculine enough (in case they were women wanting to usurp men's power). People wearing 'women's clothes'1 were affected by other laws if they were not judged to look feminine enough (in case they were men wanting to conceal their identity for nefarious purposes, or wanting to cause a public disturbance).

Not Forbidden

Berthold Buttgereit was born on 23 February, 1891 in Berlin. Named Bertha Emma Charlotte by his parents, as a child he preferred joining in with boys' games than spending time with girls. He had one sister and his parents died when he was fairly young.

In 1896, Dr Magnus Hirschfeld moved to Berlin and came to prominence as an outspoken supporter of rights for people in sexual minorities. In 1909 his assessment of someone known only as Käthe T as wearing the clothing that corresponded to the person's inner self enabled Käthe to obtain a 'Transvestite Pass' from the police in 1910. The pass confirmed that the police were aware that Käthe was known for wearing men's clothing.

Berthold visited Dr Hirschfeld in 19122 and received a 'Transvestite Pass' that enabled him to live comfortably as a man privately, publicly and professionally. In 1918 he received a travel pass to go to Cologne, and on the back was written 'Bertha Buttgereit is not forbidden to wear men's clothes'. On 8 November, 1920 he officially changed his name to Berthold.

Soon after changing his name, he applied for a licence to marry his girlfriend (as they had been living together for eight years) but when the register office saw his birth certificate, the application was refused. Berthold went to court to try to change his birth certificate, but the outcome of the case was not recorded.

What is known from the Cologne Address Book and Telephone Book records is that Berthold worked as a bookkeeper, even during the time of the Nazis3 (perhaps helped by Berthold being blond and blue-eyed so he didn't draw attention to himself in any other way). He worked his way up to the role of Office Manager by 1950 and became a pensioner in 1958. He disappeared from the Telephone Book in 1984, when he was 93.

Passes

Over time, laws have been criticised and convictions overturned. For example, in 1975 the case of City of Columbus vs John Rogers noted that:

Modes of dress for both men and women are historically subject to changes in fashion. At the present time, clothing is sold for both sexes which is so similar in appearance that 'a person of ordinary intelligence' might not be able to identify it as male or female dress.

In 1978 the case of City of Chicago v Wallace Wilson identified that:

Absent evidence to the contrary, we cannot assume that individuals who cross-dress for purposes of therapy are prone to commit crimes.

In spite of those realisations, the law can still cause problems. For example in 2004 an African American women's football player was arrested in a restaurant after she used the ladies' toilet when someone made a complaint. Controversially, in 2016 in the US state of North Carolina, HB2 was passed. HB2 included a clause making it illegal for people to use a single-sex public toilet that did not match the sex on their birth certificates. However, it was roundly criticised, not least because it was never made clear how that clause would be enforced. In March 2017 the clause was repealed.

Thus, many transgender, intersex and gender nonconforming people still fear they will be judged not to 'pass' (ie they may not match the informal gender police's expectations of male or female appearance) putting them at risk of verbal abuse or physical violence.

However, the story of Berthold Buttgereit gives hope that there will be a time when everyone can be themselves without fearing the gender police.

1Inverted commas are used here, because as Eddie Izzard once said, 'They're not women's clothes - they're my clothes'.2Hirschfeld took photographs of Berthold wearing 'men's clothes' and 'women's clothes' and published them in his 1930 book Geschlechtskunde Vol 5, without mentioning Berthold's name.3Around 20,000 of the 25,000 books that featured in the famous photographs of Nazi book burnings on 10 May, 1933 were from Magnus Hirschfeld's Institut für Sexualwissenschaft (Institute of Sex Research).

Bookmark on your Personal Space


Entry

A87903543

Infinite Improbability Drive

Infinite Improbability Drive

Read a random Edited Entry


Written and Edited by

Disclaimer

h2g2 is created by h2g2's users, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the Not Panicking Ltd. Unlike Edited Entries, Entries have not been checked by an Editor. If you consider any Entry to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please register a complaint. For any other comments, please visit the Feedback page.

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more