A Conversation for Scrubs - The TV Series

Peer Review: A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 1

Bagpuss

Entry: Scrubs - The TV Series - A829884
Author: Bagpuss - U152404

I think this is doĆ­ng quite nicely. Any comments?


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 2

Z

Me too well done! Have you seen a "uk vairent" of this sort of programe TLC? which is also quiet good though someone may shoot me down for this

smiley - giftsmiley - brr


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 3

cafram - in the states.

The theme song's by a band called Lazlo Bane, if you wanted to include that? smiley - erm

smiley - musicalnote


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 4

McKay The Disorganised

I don't think TLC is as good, because the characters are not as deep, but its still funny.

Tricky trying to describe to someone who hasn't seen it. Whilst whats written betters what I could do, I still feel it misses out the levels of interaction between the characters.

Suggestion smiley - tit What about some of the features of a typical episode - the "war" between medical and surgical - Elliot's dysfunctional family - JD's fantasy/nightmare sequences.

I dunno - its a difficult one to write up, I think I would have gone through a typical episode, and as each charcter appeared given there characteristics as footnotes. But that would mean completely re-writing it.

smiley - erm Not being very helpful here am I ?


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 5

Oberon2001 (Scout)

I like the entry smiley - ok
Just a typo I spotted though ->
>>A lazy reviewer might would describe Scrubs as "a comedy version of ER."<<
err... "might would"? smiley - huh

But hey, what's a typo really? Just a collection of letters strung together...
Oberon2001


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 6

Uncle Heavy [sic]

theres a lot more to be said about the characters. doctor cox is one of the best sitcom characters in history, for instance, and mroe needs to be said of his complexities. in fact, more needs to be said about all of them, and also more needs to be discussed of the series, likehow the humour works, and the surreal dream sequences and whatnot...


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 7

cafram - in the states.

Saying something about Dr Cox caring about the patients and Dr Evil (the old boss guy smiley - erm) caring about money could be good...I've just seen the episode where the have a dual with lightsabres - very good description of them - Darth/Obi Wan...


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 8

Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences

Still working on this one bagpuss? For the record, I think TLC is better, if only because the characters are nasty buggers, and there's no irritating 'heart-warming' message at the end smiley - grr

smiley - ale


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 9

Bagpuss

Working on it in the braod sense of not having finished it, yes. I'm meaning to do it some time.

I've not seen TLC (is it UK or US? I forget where you are).


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 10

Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences

It's UK. It stars, umm, that bloke from Pie in the Sky, one of the League of Gentlemen, and another bloke who's name escapes me. Gosh, that was useful wasn't it?

smiley - ale


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 11

Bagpuss

Sounds good.


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 12

J

I thought it was US. I know it's on here at 8:30 on NBC thursdays. This is considered one of the most turbulent timeslots of TV, multitudes of shows have come and gone from this slot, but only Scrubs brought in enough viewers.

Yeah, I like the show too.

smiley - blacksheep


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 13

Bagpuss

Scrubs is US (the concerns over who has and hasn't got insurance should give that away), it was TLC we were discussing.

What's going on lately though? Past two weeks they're showing Friends instead. smiley - yuk


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 14

J

Oh, I misunderstood. I've been watching Scrubs from the beginning, if you need some future clarification.

smiley - blacksheep


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 15

Mikey the Humming Mouse - A3938628 Learn More About the Edited Guide!

I think this entry is quite good, but I really do agree with whoever said that it needs something in the way of describing some typical episodes. After reading this entry I know a decent amount about the characters, and a little about the flavor of the show, but I know nothing about what *happens* on the show.

I've more or less stopped watching NBC, myself, as Friends and Will&Grace have plummeted down the commode...

Mikey


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 16

J

I never liked Will and Grace.

smiley - blacksheep


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 17

Friar

Scrubs is the only show I watch on NBC.

I like the entry, of course it's impossible to picture the show well without having seen it, but overall nice job.

Bagpus, are you still working on this?

Friar


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 18

Bagpuss

Erm... Working is a very exact term.


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 19

Elentari

I like the programme and the entry is a good introduction but maybe it needs more detail, a link to the official website and maybe some of the best quotes from the programme. Good work though! smiley - smiley


A829884 - Scrubs - The TV Series

Post 20

Gordon, Ringer of Bells, Keeper of Postal Codes and Maps No One Can Re-fold Properly

Are there more changes to be made or are you done, Bagpuss? smiley - smiley


smiley - teasmiley - towel


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more