When h2g2 implemented a choice of skins during Ripley ver 1.0 in June of 2000, I was as skeptical as were many other h2g2 users.
Why the change? Everybody loved h2g2's goo. It was part of the site's charm.
But I figured if h2g2 created it, there must be a reason for it, so I started using Alabaster. As time passed, I became enamoured with the new
layout, the function buttons and the double ad banners.
As time passed (with me continuing to use Alabaster), I started to wonder what skins some of my online friends were using. So I asked. This led me
to wonder about skin use on the entire site. So I asked again.
The results of my queries follow:
The most logical place to go was in the Ask h2g2 forums - I couldn't think of a better way to poll the entire community.
A total of 71 votes were cast in the forum. Of course, exactly 42 Researchers voted for Classic Goo. Twenty-one voted for Alabaster. Eight use both skins.
Many of the voters gave erudite reasons for their choices:
John-the-GURUdener said he prefers Goo because:
'Alabaster looks much too institutional, whereas the dark blue of Goo is just like looking into the night sky... with a blob of green mucous inexplicably stuck in one corner'.
Colonel Sellers voted for Alabaster because:
'The thing I view most on H2G2 is my own homepage (call me egocentric), and my chief purpose there is to check up on updated forums. I hate having to scroll down half the page every time I return to my homepage in goo. Alabaster puts all the most important info and functions on top, where they belong'.
Archangle Tweetie prefers Goo because:
'I just find Alabaster a bit cold looking - Goo is warmer, unique, and fits the site perfectly. It's just like looking into the galaxy at night.'
Duncan 'Spearcarrier' Jones likes Alabaster because:
'it looks more like SQL (which I'm supposed to be doing) from 12.2
I chose to poll the members of Floor 42 simply because they represent an older population of h2g2 users who don't tend to hang around in the Ask h2g2 forums.
The results were a surprising 15 in favour of Goo and 10 in favour of Alabaster. I say surprising here because one would have expected long-time users to be more unwilling to change to the new skin, but the percentages were much closer than those of the community at large.