h2g2 The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy: Earth Edition

http://www.h2g2.com/A463691 the Sedgwick Geological Trail is one place
about which the world wide web says practically nothing. Here is a
chance for h2g2 to get there first. I personally visited the place.
Here is what I have to say on it.

I like it. I'd recommend this for the Guide, as it's written in the right spirit, and fairly informative. It could, however, be more informative for non-geologists (like me). This - along with the possible non-inclusion of the external reference, and subsequently required further explanation - is the only reservation I'd place on its recommendation, though.

This entry to the Peer Review could also do with an edit before it's confined to the Sin Bin for flaunting the standard format (see original Peer Review page for details)

http://www.h2g2.com/PeerReview

Oh dear.
First person.
This would be a great entry re-written.
Please re-write then re-submit, remember to type the name of your entry in the subject box as well, so people can see at a glance what's in the Peer Review
Thanks!

I second the sin-binning - it may seem like a petty thing, but this sort of thing makes running peer review harder than it has to be... and co-incidentally reduces the amount of comment your entry will get...

I'll read the entry when it's resubmitted

I'll second the sin-binning and resubmitting of the article with the correct heading

Aren't you actually 'thirding' the Sin-Binning, Looney?

It's hard to get reliable staff these days

Oh, I second that!

oh, who seconded it?

Editorial Note: This conversation has been moved from 'Peer Review Sin Bin' to 'Sedgwick Geological Trail'.

Back to Entry - this became Edited Entry A593606 Sedgwick Geological Trail