Understanding Literary Plots

1 Conversation

There is plenty of help available to the aspiring writer, in classes, on the internet, on television, and in books. Much of it leaves the finer points of description, dialogue, and details to the creative mind and focuses, instead, on helping the writer to construct a viable plot.

It has often been claimed that there are only seven basic plots from which all literary works are derived. It has also been claimed that there are 30, 20, 10, 36, or one plot from which all others flow.

Defining our term:

A sampling of definitions for 'Plot':

Verb: To plan secretly, usually something illegal
Noun: A secret scheme to do something
Literary: The story that is told in a novel or performance
Gardening: A small area of ground covered by specific vegetation
Technical: A diagram, schematic or technical drawing that shows interactions among components, or how something is constructed
Mathematic: A chart or map showing the movements, progress, or results of an object or process

As you will probably have noticed, all of these versions have related meanings in that each refers to the description of something that is not known until the 'plot' has been completed. In this way we can see that there is really only one definition for 'Plot'*.

You may recognise the previous paragraph to be a bit of sophistry, perhaps even sophomoric. Well, it was intentionally provided to make this discussion more understandable and less controversial. The fact is that people like to group things, distill things, and present things in ways that make them easier to digest, remember, discuss, or merely argue over. This distillation, however, does not always clarify meanings.

Remember that anything said after this point is in regard to easing the use of the information, not to dogmatically hold to a theory defending it against all others.

Caution! Critical Thinking Ahead!

Here are some BAD descriptions of the 'Plot' concept, that you might run across if surfing the internet, to start you off:

Plot is the essence, the actual storyline of what is happening in a written or performed work. It generally refers to a very brief overview of the story, but it really can be as detailed as you make it. It can leave out particular details that are plot twists in order that these aren't revealed until the person watching/reading the story gets to them.

This is not a 'Plot' at all. What this 'definition' actually describes is a synopsis.

Plot is the skeletal system of a story. It contains the web of events that make up the entire story, as well as literary patterns and devices, which are incorporated to create the story's essence. It is divided into 6 Basic Components, namely: Exposition, Initial Incident, Rising Action, Climax, Falling Action, and Ending. This kind of categorization, however, may vary according to a writer's point of view.

We must be thankful for the Caveat; for this is also not so much a definition of 'Plot', but of a story's dynamic flow (similar to biorythms). Useful to understand, but misidentified.

Encyclopedia Britannica: in fiction, the structure of interrelated actions, consciously selected and arranged by the author. Plot involves a considerably higher level of narrative organization than normally occurs in a story or fable. According to E.M. Forster in Aspects of the Novel (1927), a story is a “narrative of events arranged in their time-sequence,” whereas a plot organizes the events according to a “sense of causality.”

This definition is much better, except that we know of many 'stories' that are a 'narrative of events', but wherein those events are not arranged any normal form of time sequence. And, what could the encylopedia mean by organizing events by a 'sense of causality'?

Let's try separating the Story from the Plot:

The 'Story' is represented in the finished work, whether we're talking about a short story, a novel, a movie, or a theatrical performance. It can be summarized or synopsised, but then it becomes a summary or synopsis.

The 'Plot' is the structure and relationship of characters and events, designed to produce a particular effect, emotion, or message. It is a higher level of the story than the summary or synopsis (a 50,000 foot view as opposed to a 10,000 foot view).

The story does not have to flow in chronological order. It may not neatly link all of the main characters. It may not explore anything other than a linear path of events. A plot does not have this luxury.

If the story doesn't have a plot it may wind up being a 10,000 word journal about somebody's life, that just describes what had happened until the 10,000th word was reached (imagine Mary Shelly's Frankenstein without any reference to sewing bits of dead people together and the results).

Categorizing Plots:

The 36 Dramatic Situations

Georges Polti created Thirty-Six Dramatic Situations to categorize every dramatic situation that might occur in a story or performance by analysing classical Greek texts, French works, and others (continuing the work of Carlo Gozzi and his 36 'Situations').

Supplication

Deliverance

Crime pursued by vengeance

Vengeance taken for kin upon kin

Pursuit

Disaster

Falling prey to cruelty/misfortune

Revolt

Daring enterprise

Abduction

The enigma

Obtaining

Enmity of kin

Rivalry of kin

Murderous adultery

Madness

Fatal imprudence

Involuntary crimes of love

Slaying of kin unrecognized

Self-sacrifice for an ideal

Self-sacrifice for kin

All sacrificed for passion

Necessity of sacrificing loved ones

Rivalry of superior vs. inferior

Adultery

Crimes of love

Discovery of the dishonour of a loved one

Obstacles to love

An enemy loved

Ambition

Conflict with a god or gods

Mistaken jealousy

Erroneous judgement

Remorse

Recovery of a lost one

Loss of loved ones

An IPL (Internet Public Library) list includes just these seven fairly expansive plot concepts:

man/woman vs. nature

man/woman vs. man/woman

man/woman vs. the environment

man/woman vs. machines/technology

man/woman vs. the supernatural

man/woman vs. self

man/woman vs. god/religion

A gross, simplification of Booker's list:

Christopher Booker's book, "Seven Basic Plots -- why we tell stories" (which took him 35 years to write), looks quite different. For example, the previous list's man vs X plots above would all seem to fall under "overcoming the monster".

Overcoming the monster: defeating a force which threatens safety, existence, success.
The Quest: a group in search of something (who may find it or something 'better').
Journey and Return: the hero journeys away from home and comes back (having experienced something and
maybe having changed for the better).
Comedy: not neccesarily haha funny. a misunderstanding or ignorance is created that keeps parties apart, which is resolved, by the end, bringing them back together.
Tragedy: Someone, tempted (vanity, greed, etc), becomes increasingly desperate, or trapped by their actions, until the climax where they usually die.
Rebirth: hero is captured or oppressed (a living death existence) until they are miraculously freed.
Rags to Riches: overcoming a state of poverty, want, and/or need.

This is not to say that stories don't jump in at places other than their chronological starting point; or leave early, leaving us feeling unsatisfied. His theory, that there only seven basic plots, is connected strongly to the psychology of Jung, the Ego and the Self. But then, at the end of his book, Booker adds two more plots: Rebellion and Mystery, which both sound like versions of 'overcoming the monster'

Ronald B. Tobias wrote of 20 Master Plots:

Quest

Adventure

Pursuit

Rescue

Escape

Revenge

The Riddle

Rivalry

Underdog

Temptation

Metamorphosis

Transformation

Maturation

Love

Forbidden Love

Sacrifice

Discovery

Wretched Excess

Ascension

Descension.

Foster-Harris wrote The Basic Patterns of Plot

He contended that there are three basic patterns of plot:
Type A, happy ending; central character makes a sacrifice (a decision that seems logically "wrong") for the sake of another.
Type B, unhappy ending; central character does what seems logically "right" and thus fails to make the needed sacrifice.
Type C, literary plot; in which the outcome does not hinge upon decision, but fate; the critical event may take place at the beginning of the story rather than the end. What follows is inevitable and, often, tragic.

Shakespeare's two cents:

Of course one could always break plots down to simply Comedy and Tragedy based, as Shakespeare did. In Tragedies, everybody dies; and, in comedies, at least the protagonist lives.

Additional categorisation:

In addition to Seven Literary Plots, there is also the concept of the Seven Basic Needs for a story line.
Hero/Protagonist – the person whose actions and decisions we follow, set against a larger background.
Hero’s Character Flaw – a physical, emotional, or psycholgical (even spiritual) weakness or defense mechanism that prevents the hero from being complete; because the growth/maturity of characters is so critical to stories.
Enabling circumstances – the surroundings the hero is in at the
beginning of the story, which allow the hero to maintain his/her
character flaw.
Opponent/Villian/Antagonist – someone who opposes the hero in getting or doing what he/she wants. Not always a truevillain, say in a romantic comedy. The opponent is the person who instigates a life-changing event.
Ally/Friend/Helper/Mate – the person who spends a lot of time with the hero and helps the hero overcome his/her character flaw.
Life-changing event – the challenge, threat or opportunity that results from the opponent, which forces the hero to respond in some way that’s related to the hero overcoming the flaw.
Jeopardy – the risks that the hero must take to overcome the flaw, dramatic events that lend excitement and challenge to the quest.

Thankfully, many writers - like most creative types - learn how to throw away all the basics tenets and come up with new and fresh combinations and exclusions, like 'machines/technology v the supernatural', to keep things interesting.


Bookmark on your Personal Space


Entry

A38650395

Infinite Improbability Drive

Infinite Improbability Drive

Read a random Edited Entry


Written and Edited by

Disclaimer

h2g2 is created by h2g2's users, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the Not Panicking Ltd. Unlike Edited Entries, Entries have not been checked by an Editor. If you consider any Entry to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please register a complaint. For any other comments, please visit the Feedback page.

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more