A Conversation for Alan Titchmarsh

Peer Review: A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 1

Mizzpinky *sighs* here we go again

Entry: Alan Titchmarsh - A22525580
Author: Mizzpinky *sighs* here we go again - U858042

this is another I've been asked to take over


A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 2

Icy North

I don't understand why this was taken out of PR, but please could you link to the original PR thread? That goes for the others too.

smiley - cheers Icy


A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 3

lil ~ Auntie Giggles with added login ~ returned


Previous PR thread: F7144968?thread=4108370


Again, this is Cal's work and he should be acknowledge.


A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 4

Mizzpinky *sighs* here we go again

yes we are all quite aware that it is Cal's work lil


A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 5

lil ~ Auntie Giggles with added login ~ returned

Then I shall leave you to supply the PR threads for the rest.


A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 6

Mina

I wrote a load of stuff, then the pc crashed, so here it is again, but briefly.

The title should be expanded a bit - he's not that famous that everyone will know who he is.

Alan Titchmarsh - Presenter, Writer and Gardener or something similar.

"Chelsea flower show in 1983, he has gone done this every year right up" Extra 'gone' that you don't need there I think.

"Gardeners World, filming it from his own back garden" All presenters, prior to Monty Don presented from their back gardens. This makes it sound as if it was just him, but it was traditional.

"Unfortunately Alan left the show in 2002" This is opinion. I'm sure it wasn't unfortunate for Alan at all, otherwise he wouldn't have done it.

All show titles should be in italics, not quotes.

It would be useful to also know what he's doing now. Is he still writing fact or fiction, going back to journalism - does he have any newspaper columns for instance - or is he going to be back on our telly soon? This is one of the reasons I'm against writing entries on living people - they have the annoying habit of continuing to do things which we then need to update!




A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 7

Mina

Are you working on this? Or any of the others you've put into PR?


A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 8

Gnomon - time to move on

If it is Cal's work, then you should add Cal to the author list.

Gardeners World should be Gardeners' World.


A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 9

Gnomon - time to move on

Mizzpinky, are you working on this?

When you put something into Peer Review and people make suggestions, you should either carry out the suggestions or explain why you are not going to.


A22525580 - Alan Titchmarsh

Post 10

BigAl Patron Saint of Left Handers Keeper of the Glowing Pickle and Monobrows

'Who created quite a large male following by not wearing a bra'.

It is interesting to note (to me, at least) that despite the fact that Charlie always maintained that she went bra-free out of personal choice, because it was more comfortable when doing that sort of manual labour, as soon as AT left the show, and when Charlie also started presenting her own shows, she suddenly started wearing these abysmal smiley - handcuffs

smiley - grr


Key: Complain about this post