A Conversation for Circular Reasoning

Begging the Question

Post 1

The Artist formerly known as Hullabaloo

This entry is clear, concise and accurate smiley - ok

I'd like to add, though, that in logic this fallacy is also known as 'begging the question' (from Aristotle) - which means assuming what you're trying to prove instead of questioning it - letting the question go begging. Lucinda (et al) describes this fallacy very clearly.

The phrase is much misused by journalists, sociologists, and others who can't understand the concept. These people imagine that 'begging the question' or 'begs the question' is some higher and more impressive-sounding form of 'demands/ invites the question' (e.g. of what politician x was doing with financier y), but it doesn't mean this at all.

Hull smiley - artistsmiley - smiley



Begging the Question

Post 2

Decaf Silicon

Oh, goody. I've been using that phrase wrongly for years. Good to know.


Begging the Question

Post 3

The Artist formerly known as Hullabaloo

DS -

smiley - cheerup There is the argument that this usage is now so common that it's become accepted as correct. I don't agree with that, but there may be a point there.

Hull smiley - artistsmiley - smiley



Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more