A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Could zombies exist?

Post 1

winnoch2 - Impostair Syndromair Extraordinaire

...theoretically if a disease/virus/bacteria evolved that symbiotically survived and kept alive the cerebellum and other key regions of the brain, not involved with consciousness?

We know that the cerebellum is often described as a primitive, almost stand-alone part of the brain which controls autonomous functions. If it combined with the regions responsible for motor skills and sensory input.. could zombie like post-death humans 'come alive' craving flesh to sustain its virus/bacterial hosts ? smiley - bigeyes


Could zombies exist?

Post 2

Deb

Terry Pratchett describes the efforts involved in being a zombie in one of his books (*wracks brains*) (*gives up and Googles it instead*) - Reaper Man. Really funny. Could be a useful read if it ever did happen as it might give you some pointers on how to cope smiley - biggrin

Deb smiley - cheerup


Could zombies exist?

Post 3

~ jwf ~ scribblo ergo sum

Microbial species control most of our bodily functions,
mental capacities, beliefs, behaviour and emotions.
smiley - spider
The term zombie and the voodoo experience that inspired
the zombie mythos are much misunderstood - when in fact
we are all zombies to some degree.
smiley - skull
~jwf~


Could zombies exist?

Post 4

paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant

Even if zombies existed [which I don't think is possible], their nature might be quite different from what we see in zombie movies. But I like zombie jokes, like the one in the funny pages today, in which vegetarian zombies invade houses to eat bran flakes. smiley - laugh
Quikc, hide the tofu, the zombies are coming! smiley - rofl


Could zombies exist?

Post 5

Baron Grim

Zombies do exist... in the insect world. Cordyceps fungus turns various insect species into zombies with no control over their bodies. I know of no physiological reason that some fungus couldn't evolve to treat us similarly.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuKjBIBBAL8


Could zombies exist?

Post 6

Xanatic

For humans, toxoplasmosis gondi already seems to have some mind control.

It all depends what you mean by zombies. The rabies virus gives similar results, but much slower than in the movies. It also tends to kill it's host.


Could zombies exist?

Post 7

Pastey

As BG and Xantic say, Zombies do already exist to a certain extent.

To fully answer the question though, we to define what a zombie actually is.


Could zombies exist?

Post 8

Baron Grim

Sorry, that can't be done. People can't even decide between fast moving zombies and slow moving zombies.

How are zombies different from mummies other than a bit of wrapping?


Could zombies exist?

Post 9

Xanatic

For one thing, mummification isn't contagious.

There's an article by Robert Smith? about the neurology of zombies. You might find it interesting,


Could zombies exist?

Post 10

Baron Grim

Sheldon Cooper agrees.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ACDjzQkLLA


Could zombies exist?

Post 11

Mr. X ---> "Be excellent to each other. And party on, dudes!"

"How are zombies different from mummies other than a bit of wrapping?"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FVnlUCZwGKU

smiley - pirate


Could zombies exist?

Post 12

Mr. X ---> "Be excellent to each other. And party on, dudes!"

smiley - simpost

Sorry. You should probably use Baron Grim's instead.

smiley - pirate


Could zombies exist?

Post 13

Baron Grim

OOH!... Sychronicity/Lattice o' Coincidence



I just saw this list of 10 bizarre medical conditions and one presents quite zombie like behaviour.

http://www.iflscience.com/health-and-medicine/10-strangest-known-medical-conditions


"Cotard’s Delusion isn’t a physical affliction, but a rare mental disorder in which a person sincerely believes he or she is missing body parts—such as the brain—or is actually dead. Sufferers tend not to eat or bathe, and they often spend time in cemeteries, wishing to be among their own kind. Well, their perceived own kind, at any rate.

This disorder has been connected to a dysfunction in the areas of the brain responsible for recognizing and associating emotions with faces, including their own. This causes a complete emotional detachment and removes any sense of personal identity when looking at their bodies. Medications can be used to treat the condition, though electroconvulsive therapy has worked better in some cases."


Could zombies exist?

Post 14

paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant

Thorazine used to be associated with zombie-like shuffling.


Could zombies exist?

Post 15

ITIWBS

Posting now so I don't lose this thread.

...from the 1st post, that should be 'limbic', not 'cerebellum'. smiley - run....ciao...


Could zombies exist?

Post 16

Baron Grim

Speaking of the cerebellum (or, not as the case may be) a 24 year old woman was recently discovered to be missing her cerebellum.

http://www.wired.com/2014/09/24-woman-discovers-born-without-key-brain-region-cerebellum/


Could zombies exist?

Post 17

ITIWBS

The limbic regions of the brain include everything inside the the white areas and below, along the course of the spinal cord, including the medulla oblongata in the brain diagram accompaning the article in the link above about a woman born without a cerebellum.

The cerebellum and cerebrum represent higher structures not present in the reptilian or avian brain.

Archetypal limbic personification:

Godzilla 1954 Trailer: http://youtu.be/VKrj1ymJzmo

The body language, at any rate matches the description and the stereotype.


Could zombies exist?

Post 18

ITIWBS

Some links below on one of the best established and documented outsider studies available on Haitian Voodoo and the zombie cult.

It was thought that the drugs used in the ritual were derived from hetbal sources.

They proved instead to be derived from the puffer fish.

http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/31490.The_Serpent_and_the_Rainbow

serpent and the rainbow full movie: http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL7D4656EF96D8888C

smiley - evilgrin...by Jormungand, the world girdling serpent and Heimdal who guards Bifrost, the rainbow bridge, death itself is no escape from old Voudun, the Cargo God...


Could zombies exist?

Post 19

paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant

"The cerebellum and cerebrum represent higher structures not present in the reptilian or avian brain." [ITIWBS]

Birds and reptiles manage fine without these structures, so it's not implausible for humans to manage likewise. It's just not common for them to be without them.....


Could zombies exist?

Post 20

Peanut

'Birds and reptiles manage fine without these structures, so it's not implausible for humans to manage likewise. It's just not common for them to be without them.....'

While there are cases were people manage just fine quoting from the article the BG linked too

'There are reasons to guard against hyping cases such as this. The overwhelming majority of people who suffer brain injuries and illnesses often face great challenges and difficulties coping with the impairments associated with their conditions.'

and

'By sensationalising rare cases like this Chinese woman, we risk belittling the seriousness of the vast majority of brain disorders and injuries and generating unrealistic hope about the brain’s plasticity.'

I do note your use of the word implausible, but find your comment, in terms of your comparisons to be somewhat lacking in sensitivity




Key: Complain about this post