A Conversation for The Mornington Crescent Appreciation Society

Commented game - medium to high level

Post 1

Santragenius V

I've been wondering about this for a while - even since I read one of teh last interviews with Mrs Trellis where she reluctantly told about a commented series of games she'd followed in her youth and offhandedly remarked how inspiring that had been for her early career.

Why not take up that gauntlet?

I suggest a format in which the play is announced, followed by a line with a few dashes and then the enlightning comments. And please, keep to comments - we are in no way suggesting breaking the number one rule of not explaining this the most honourable of all games.

So, referring to the house list of variants and rules in play, I would like to open with:

Hackney Central
-----
Both a homage to the eraly origins of the game itself AND staying within both Euston and Victoria clauses.


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 2

pljones

Well, hackney cabs may well be a bit hackneyed and the East London Line may be past its sell-by but this does seem to be something of a cracking idea - a bit like the points on the Jubilee Line, I hear.

I think the O'Reilly Origins of the game are less disputed, myself but Reverse-Badgering may yet fail to avoid violation of Rule 221b. That being the case, and as you've already gone Overground, despite the poor punctuation: Gallions Reach.


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 3

pljones

(Gosh, my attention span needs some repair work...)


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 4

el D – for the sake of brevity and out of respect for my fellow Glums

Gant's Hill

---------------

Whilst being neither Gant nor Hill, does bring us into line with the pre-war austerity rules and a stark reminder that those days are behind us now and should stay that way.


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 5

Santragenius V

Old Street

-----------

Standard rule book play smiley - smiley


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 6

el D – for the sake of brevity and out of respect for my fellow Glums

Finchley Road and Frognal

----------------------------

Emerging from austerity toward utility


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 7

pljones

Russell Square

----------------------------

The rules for measuring austerity do not necessarily apply, particularly in light of the Osmonds ruling of 1975. Though this does need an extra blue chip played.


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 8

Santragenius V

Mile End

-----

Central Stations also allowed under austerity - as well as under War Provision Rationing Rules, which I call now.

*places Central Line Red chip next to the blue one*


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 9

el D – for the sake of brevity and out of respect for my fellow Glums

White City

-------------

Ah now, red chips I can do!


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 10

pljones

Bank!

-------------

Definitely no Worple Financial Index after that. I quite fancy some chips, though.


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 11

Santragenius V

Holborn

---------

Not to be in nid...


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 12

el D – for the sake of brevity and out of respect for my fellow Glums

Dalston Kingsland

-----------------------

With a hey and a ho and a hey-nonny-no...


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 13

pljones

Dollis Hill

-----------------

And I'm very much afraid I'll have to take issue with issuing hey-nonny-nos without a by-your-leave. I'd find the appropriate ruling to quote but I'm sure you know the one I mean.


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 14

Santragenius V

Hammersmtih

-------

Prett standard inversion.
I have the, ummm, 13th edition of Stovold's, I'm sure there is indeed something about inappropriate hey-nonny-nos in there somewhere...


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 15

el D – for the sake of brevity and out of respect for my fellow Glums

South Kenton

------------------

Yes, quite right. Stovolds has it. Always worth a try though eh?

smiley - smiley


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 16

pljones

Queensway

------------------

Not to be mixed up with Queensbury. The rules are very different. And Queensbury sales aren't the same.


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 17

el D – for the sake of brevity and out of respect for my fellow Glums

Waterloo
----------------

Just feeling like an amble along the South Bank


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 18

Santragenius V

Kew Gardens

--------

A vertical shunt; confirmed legal by the Osmonds ruling of 1975
(and nice to take a walk and a look at the flowers there, btw smiley - smiley)


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 19

pljones

Wimbledon Park

-----------

Whilst there have been some recent variations introduced that may affect how the fifteenth Victoria clause is interpreted, a careful shunting manoeuvre can still be effective.


Commented game - medium to high level

Post 20

el D – for the sake of brevity and out of respect for my fellow Glums

Wembley Central

------------------

Even Stovolds leaves some room for creativity
smiley - smiley


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more