SUNDAY
19th May 2013
Text only
Become a member
Sign in
Front Page
Help!
Feedback
Who is Online
This is the Conversation Forum for H2G2 Speaker's Corner
<< The new religion...
Religion - "It's Only A Model" A2986284 >>


Prev | Next
Subject: Why Does God Let Us Suffer? A logical viewpoint from the Bible (A3430090) - SC
Posted Dec 20, 2004 by 4502114
Post: 1



Write a reply to this Posting

Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Prev | Next
Subject: Why Does God Let Us Suffer? A logical viewpoint from the Bible (A3430090) - SC
Posted Dec 20, 2004 by Blatherskite the Mugwump - Bandwidth Bandit
This is a reply to this Posting
Post: 2

The number of assumptions that underly an argument like this is staggering. And it doesn't matter how much scholarship you invest in a piece like this if the underlying assumptions can't be supported. It's like trying to build a skyscraper on the foundation of a house of cards.

The keystone card would be "there is a God," and there certainly is not. But then the writer takes further liberties. For example,

"How long will these difficult times last? Jesus' disciples asked more or less the same question. But Jesus did not give them a specific day or hour when this misery-stricken system of things would end. Instead, Jesus said: "He that has endured to the end is the one that will be saved." (Matthew 24:3, 13) Jesus' words encourage us to take a long-range view. We must be prepared to endure many unpleasant situations before the end finally comes."

Actually, when questioned, Jesus did not give them a specific day or hour, but he did assure them that it would all happen during the span of their natural lives (Matt 16:28, 23:36, 24:34, 26:64, Mark 9:1, 13:30, 14:62, Luke 9:27, 21:32, John 21:22). You have to ignore an awful lot of scripture to believe God is biding his time. Either it already happened and nobody noticed, or it never happened and is a false prophecy.

This is how you write an article on Christianity with the solid foundation of reason: A213247


Write a reply to this Posting

Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Prev | Next
Subject: Why Does God Let Us Suffer? A logical viewpoint from the Bible (A3430090) - SC
Posted Dec 20, 2004 by Stealth "Jack" Azathoth
This is a reply to this Posting
Post: 3

And you can read Blatherskite entry on the US being the first true democracy for further info on how not write an article that stands up to scrutiny.winkeye
An easy to follow link to the original poster's entry for those interested... A3430090

peacedove


Write a reply to this Posting

Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Prev | Next
Subject: Why Does God Let Us Suffer? A logical viewpoint from the Bible (A3430090) - SC
Posted Dec 20, 2004 by Blatherskite the Mugwump - Bandwidth Bandit
This is a reply to this Posting
Post: 4

That was one ill-considered statement in the introduction to an otherwise very well done article. Quite a different situation altogether.

Write a reply to this Posting

Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Prev | Next
Subject: Why Does God Let Us Suffer? A logical viewpoint from the Bible (A3430090) - SC
Posted Dec 20, 2004 by Stealth "Jack" Azathoth
This is a reply to this Posting
Post: 5

Just a joke... I was too tired to read it properly. When I get a chance and if I feel the need I'll let you know "very well done" I consider it.

peacedove


Write a reply to this Posting

Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Prev | Next
Subject: Why Does God Let Us Suffer? A logical viewpoint from the Bible (A3430090) - SC
Posted Dec 20, 2004 by Blatherskite the Mugwump - Bandwidth Bandit
This is a reply to this Posting
Post: 6

I know you meant it as a joke, but it's a sore point for me. I've always hated the fact that once the editors get hold of an article, there's nothing further you can do about it. That comment slipped past me and the editor, and there's nothing to do now but get reminded of the mistake on a regular basis.

Write a reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting



< Show Older | Show Newer >
1
Conversation list


© BBC MMII
Terms & Conditions | Privacy