Front Page

Life | The Universe | Everything | Advanced Search
 
Front PageReadTalkContributeHelp!FeedbackWho is Online

or register to join or start a new conversation.

 
This is the Conversation Forum for Bus-Stop Logic
<< Too True.
Forcing the bus to turn up >>

Subject: Bemused by links to 'referenced' entries
Posted Dec 3, 2003 by
Pimms
 
Posting 1

Next Posting
Usually I expect the links to other entries to have been referenced somewhere within the entry itself - that way you can usually appreciate the relevance of the reference.

With this entry the links to entries on propositional logic, completeness, consistency and the liar's paradox, while clearly to do with 'logic', have nothing to do with this entry, and unsurprisingly have no 'reference' in the body of the entry.


I like the entry though biggrin and also liked the bus stop pontoon entry.

Pimms smiley


Reply
Read the First Reply to this Posting

Click here to register a complaint about this Posting
Subject: Bemused by links to 'referenced' entries
Posted Dec 3, 2003 by
Geggs (QoTD Operator) Have you seen something Quotable? Send it to qotd@h2g2.com now! Not sure how? See A87794383
This is a reply to this Posting  
Posting 2

Previous PostingNext Posting
If you look at the test version of the page - test1941554 - scroll dowm to the bottom and you'll see a section of <REFERENCES>.

That's how it's done.


Geggs

Reply
Read the First Reply to this Posting

Click here to register a complaint about this Posting
Subject: Bemused by links to 'referenced' entries
Posted Dec 3, 2003 by
Pimms
This is a reply to this Posting  
Posting 3

Previous PostingNext Posting
I suppose the point I was trying to make is that if there is to be a link to another entry then the author/editor should indicate in the entry why someone might want to try that link.

Maybe I'm being picky in this case, as the other links have titles that might by themselves be interesting to researchers reading this entry.

Nevertheless sometimes the title is less helpful, and if an entry is important/relevant enough to link to, it should be important enough to mention/justify in the entry.

Pimms

Reply
Read the First Reply to this Posting

Click here to register a complaint about this Posting
Subject: Bemused by links to 'referenced' entries
Posted Dec 3, 2003 by
Geggs (QoTD Operator) Have you seen something Quotable? Send it to qotd@h2g2.com now! Not sure how? See A87794383
This is a reply to this Posting  
Posting 4

Previous PostingNext Posting
Well, I'm fairly sure that they weren't in Yael's original entry, so they must have been added by the Eds. Sometimes references jsut get and in because they seem to fit in some way to the entry, and as this entry has Logic in the title, those other logical entries got added in.

Oh well.


Geggs

Reply
Read the First Reply to this Posting

Click here to register a complaint about this Posting
Subject: Bemused by links to 'referenced' entries
Posted Dec 4, 2003 by
Sea Change
This is a reply to this Posting  
Posting 5

Previous PostingNext Posting
I was surprised by this in other entries in the past, and was told by an italic that there was no requirement for the links to refer to anything specific in the text.

Reply
Read the First Reply to this Posting

Click here to register a complaint about this Posting
Subject: Bemused by links to 'referenced' entries
Posted Dec 4, 2003 by
Lady Pennywhistle - Coming to a city (possibly) near you this summer! Meet me in Leeds (A87792664) or in London (A87795382)! C'mon, it'll be fun!
This is a reply to this Posting  
Posting 6

Previous PostingNext Posting
Alright, I guess it's time for the (proud) author's note...
The references were mine, and were originally like that. The point is that they aren't really relevant to the entry itself, but they are related to the general subject. I got the idea from some note in Peer Review, and did it like this because I didn't know how to connect the text to it.
I don't think it's that bad... it's just some extra information, in case somebody wants to expand their horizons. smiley

Reply
Read the First Reply to this Posting

Click here to register a complaint about this Posting
Subject: Bemused by links to 'referenced' entries
Posted Dec 5, 2003 by
Pimms
This is a reply to this Posting  
Posting 7

Previous PostingNext Posting
Fair enough Yael. It was just being picky - the kind of thing I had in mind was what I put at the end of my entry on Superellipses A1053884 - just a note so that researchers who are wanting to expand their horizons at least know in what direction they are going.smiley

Reply
Read the First Reply to this Posting

Click here to register a complaint about this Posting
Subject: Bemused by links to 'referenced' entries
Posted Dec 5, 2003 by
Lady Pennywhistle - Coming to a city (possibly) near you this summer! Meet me in Leeds (A87792664) or in London (A87795382)! C'mon, it'll be fun!
This is a reply to this Posting  
Posting 8

Previous Posting
Fair enough Pimms. I guess I should have done something of that sort, but after all, this *was* my first entry... I'll know better next time. biggrin
Cool article, by the way... though the math was a bit lost on me.

Reply
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting




Already at Start of ConversationNo Older Postings to ShowNo Newer Postings to ShowAlready at End of Conversation
Postings 1-20

Conversation list




Already at Start of ConversationNo Older Postings to ShowNo Newer Postings to ShowAlready at End of Conversation
Postings 1-20

Conversation list

Front PageReadTalkContributeHelp!FeedbackWho is Online

Please note that Not Panicking Ltd is not responsible for the content of any external sites listed. The content on h2g2 is created by h2g2's Researchers, who are members of the public. Unlike Edited Guide Entries, the content on this page has not necessarily been checked by a h2g2 editor. In the event that you consider anything on this page to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please click here .


About | Help | Terms of Use