Life | The Universe | Everything | Advanced Search
 Sign in or register to join or start a new conversation.

3. Everything / Maths, Science & Technology / Physics

Lies, Damned Lies, and Science Lessons

'A little knowledge is a dangerous thing'

Adults lie to children all the time, for all sorts of reasons. Examples of common lies adults tell children include:

• Santa will only come if you're good.
• Eat your crusts, they'll make your hair curl1.
• Don't go in that cupboard or the bogeyman will get you.
• If you go out dressed like that, you'll catch a cold2.
• Mummy and Daddy are splitting up - you'll understand when you're older.

One very common reason for lying to children, however, is more defensible. The universe is a very complicated place and, if a person is ever to understand anything about it, you often have to start by teaching simplified versions of reality. 'Simplified', in this specific case, actually means 'wrong', but wrong in a particular way which makes it understandable to young minds.

Of course, at a later stage in a person's education, it is necessary to admit that what has been taught previously wasn't the truth, and then move on to a slightly more complex and more accurate lie. This process continues throughout education, until the educator is forced to admit that the answer to the question 'yes, but what is the truth?' is in fact 'er, we don't know - in fact there may not even be any such thing as objective truth. We were hoping you might help us find out - there's a PhD in it for you'.

An example of this process is as follows:

Lie Number One

Weight is constant.

If you show a typical toddler a lump of modelling clay, then roll it out into a long thin sausage shape, they often expect it to weigh more, 'because it's bigger'. It's a very simple matter to show them that in fact, because you've only changed the shape and not how much clay there is, the weight is exactly the same. So they learn that unless you add something or take it away, a kilogram of clay will always weigh a kilogram - so weight is a constant.

Lie Number Two

Weight is not a constant. What's actually constant is mass.

It eventually becomes necessary to understand that weight is dependent on gravity - if you weighed your kilogram of clay on the moon, the scale would only register about a sixth of a kilo. All the mass is still there - and since the kilogram is a unit of mass, there's still actually a kilogram of clay on your scale. It's just that the force it's exerting on the scale is very much less, due to the lower gravity. All these complications need not concern most people most of the time. Lie Number One is a forgivable simplification and the concepts of weight and mass are often used interchangeably, since most of the time we're working in a fairly consistent gravity field - that of the Earth.

Lie Number Three

Mass is not a constant, but depends on the velocity of the object, relative to lightspeed, which is a constant.

Mass as a constant works as a lie to children, because it's very, very close to the truth for things a human can see. Unfortunately, it's just as much of a lie as constant weight. In the real world, mass increases with velocity. Most of us can safely ignore this fact, however, because unless the velocity is a large fraction of the speed of light, the difference in mass is tiny. The important thing here, however, is that tiny though that difference is, it shows that Lie Number Two is a lie. It's close to the truth, but when you're talking about physics, 'close' isn't good enough.

Lie Number Four

Lightspeed is not, in fact, a constant, but may have been significantly larger than its current value during the early life of the universe.

Now we're at the edge of current knowledge. It has been suggested that lightspeed is not the universal constant that it was once assumed to be. Certain features of the observable universe, which are difficult to explain using accepted theories, can be conveniently dealt with if the speed of light is allowed to vary. Now, it should be emphasised that this is only one possible solution to a set of very difficult questions - but it shows that physicists must constantly question even the accepted wisdom of previous theories. It is in this way that science progresses. But chances are it's still not the whole truth.

The Use of Lies

Popularised simplifications of theories like evolution and relativity have two important effects. On the positive side, they allow the public to understand a little about science. On the negative side, they allow the public to understand a little about science.

Almost everything most people know about science consists of what they can remember of whatever lies-to-children were appropriate to the level where their education stopped. This is combined with whatever they've picked up from the media since. One difficulty working scientists often have is bridging the gap between what the public thinks it knows, and what the reality is.

It is therefore very important to always consider whether what you think you know about something is in fact just a lie-to-children3.

1 Who actually wants their hair to curl, anyway?
2 As though not wearing a hat actually attracts viruses...
3 The phrase 'lie to children' was coined by Ian Stewart and Jack Cohen, authors of The Collapse of Chaos and Figments of Reality.

 People have been talking about this Guide Entry. Here are the most recent Conversations:
 Related terms: (Last Posting: Oct 9, 2012) curling hair (Last Posting: Aug 7, 2011) lies (Last Posting: Aug 26, 2007) The mass velocity thing (Last Posting: May 21, 2004) The speed of light (Last Posting: Sep 15, 2003) Sorry, but no. (Last Posting: Oct 27, 2011) Perhaps your creation of this article... (Last Posting: Oct 31, 2010) teachers who lie (Last Posting: May 29, 2005) Obi-Wan Kenobi (Last Posting: Sep 15, 2003) Taught to level 3 today (Last Posting: Dec 18, 2002)

 Add your Opinion!There are tens of thousands of h2g2 Guide Entries, written by our Researchers. If you want to be able to add your own opinions to the Guide, simply become a member as an h2g2 Researcher. Tell me More!
Entry Data
Entry ID: A685055 (Edited)

Written and Researched by:
Hoovooloo

Edited by:
shazzPRME

Date: 28   February   2002

 Text only Like this page?Send it to a friend

 Referenced Guide Entries Lying Critical Mass The Liar's Paradox Gravity Inertial Frames Detecting Lies

Please note that Not Panicking Ltd is not responsible for the content of any external sites listed. The content on h2g2 is created by h2g2's Researchers, who are members of the public. Unlike Edited Guide Entries, the content on this page has not necessarily been checked by a h2g2 editor. In the event that you consider anything on this page to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please click here .